Skip to main content

View Diary: What you may not know about gun violence in Chicago (335 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  Seriously (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    cocinero, Recall, matx

    You say "Correlation does not equal causation", then you provide an example where correlation equals causation.  Do you listen to yourself?

    Here's another correlation: Violent crime drops in line with the gun ownership rate.  Fewer people with guns = less violent crime.  States with lower rates have less violent crime.  This makes sense: Notice how gun bans don't actually ban guns, they ban people from purchasing guns.  Fewer people with them... less violent crime.

    Now, that's just another correlation.  Although it does match with correlations in other countries, where fewer people with guns = less violent crime.  So it's better than the one you propose.

    Still, the most well-established explanation for the drop in crime is environmental:  Lead pollution.  Extensive and repeated research (A good summary is here has conclusively linked lead molecules in the atmosphere, mostly from leaded gasoline exhaust, to the rise in crime about 15 years after its introduction during WW2, to the fall in crime that started about 15 years after it started being phased out in the '70's.  Other factors have been ruled out, and the effect is clear in every country and city that's been tested.

    Because what these other correlations can't explain (including yours) is the truly important question:  Why crime went up in the first place.  Lead pollution explains it.  It also explains why cities got it worse than the country (more cars = more pollution), and suggest that it's no coincidence that countries still with leaded gasoline--- Afghanistan, Yemen, Iraq, North Korea, and Burma--- are not exactly peaceful friendly spots.

    Add to a drop in lead pollution: added policing, stricter prison terms, and greater moral sensibility, and you get much lower crime rates in spite of there being more guns in circulation.  We can only dream of how much more peaceful our country would be without the guns that embolden people to confrontation.

    Correlative comparisons to the number of guns out there are facile and fallacious.  You need to find new excuses.

    Conservatives need to realize that their Silent Moral Majority is neither silent, nor moral, nor a majority.

    by nominalize on Sun Feb 03, 2013 at 10:48:42 AM PST

    [ Parent ]

    •  No, no, no (1+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:

      Anyone who disagrees with Pete is "emotive" and non-logical.  Maybe I've only recently started paying attention to this, but it's amazing how often this canard arises among pro-gun types.  I'm thinking it's just projection. longer in SF.... -9.00, -7.38

      by TFinSF on Sun Feb 03, 2013 at 11:06:50 AM PST

      [ Parent ]

    •  Perhaps I did not make myself clear (0+ / 0-)

      Correlation does not PROVE causation, but correlation is necessary in order to prove causation.

      Gun ownership is at ever increasing levels, but gun crimes are steadily DROPPING. Therefore, the correlation is that MORE GUNS = LESS CRIME, not the opposite.

      Therefore the argument that reducing the amount of guns would equal a reduction in crime has no correlation in the statistics, a necessity to argue causation.

      Is this more clear?

      •  Meanwhile, in the real world.... (2+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        TFinSF, Recall

        (Second chart:) Gun ownership down, except just recently, when the death rate also stopped going down.

        You realize that a Gish Gallop only works when people are speaking face-to-face?  

        On the internet there are these things called "facts" that make it easy to verify people's claims.  And since everything we write is recorded as is, pulling the wool over people's eyes is very difficult.  Hence your frustration here.

        I suggest you stick to TV or radio.

        Conservatives need to realize that their Silent Moral Majority is neither silent, nor moral, nor a majority.

        by nominalize on Sun Feb 03, 2013 at 01:04:47 PM PST

        [ Parent ]

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site