Skip to main content

View Diary: To the self-described "patriots" of 2013: My friends, this is NOT what tyranny looks like (177 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  The point of my posing the Amish as a (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    TheFern

    counter point to your example is that every society has a range of participants and it's easy to judge FROM OUR OWN CULTURAL vantage point and from what we read in news and in history books.

    And they seem to be, if nothing else, very principled people.
    They are highly sincere, for the most part, but I'm not sure what you mean by "principled." They have a full range of social ills as the wider society does. Part of their stability, as a culture, is that people who don't toe the line are kicked out or made miserable enough that they leave "voluntarily."  

    They are also extremely restricted. Are they a police state? No. Do they tolerate ANY dissent? Hell, no!

    It is a culture in which there is no art, no musical instruments, no creative writing, no science, no literature, no statistics, no calculus, no formal teaching of deductive reasoning, no statistics, no research, (I could go on and on). Most importantly there is no approval for anyone challenging of authority (except to challenge outside authority in a few well-proscribed ways).

    There are NO gay people in the Amish, and there are NO options for women except marriage and motherhood. There is NO religious tolerance. There is no tolerance of independent thought. If you disagree you are kicked out.

    They are an example of your point that freedoms not used can be completely lost, to the point of not being aware of what freedom could be.

    And they are also an ironic study of the co-existence of extreme authoritarian control and American religious tolerance ("freedom" depending on where you fall on the religious practice spectrum), co-existing in a single culture, neither of which requires police or a military to maintain.

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site