Skip to main content

View Diary: Are you suggesting we kill all the detainees instead? (251 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  I think they should (0+ / 0-)

    keep whatever few they actually have good solid evidence on here and try them in federal court (which will cost millions of dollars, take a decade for the trial and umpteen appeals, and tie up courts from citizens'cases).  Put them in a Supermax during trial and if convicted.  If they were in genpop, they would probably get shanked anyway.

    For the rest, send them back to their home countries and let them try or release them as they like.  Whoever is refused by their home countries, send them to Afganistan with a few hundred dollars(like 5 years' income there).  If they join up with militants, then we'll kill them on the battlefield eventually anyway.

    There was that one-legged guy they released from Gitmo a few years ago.  He actually did end up back with the Taliban in Afghanistan and our troops shot him dead in a gun battle.  Of course he did manage to kill a houseful of Afghan civilians before we got him, as I recall.

    •  Our Federal courts are very good (0+ / 0-) convicting people and putting them away for long periods.

      Conviction rates are so high, in fact, that the rational response to Federal charges is to cop a plea and start planning for a stay in the pen rather than wasting money trying to get acquitted.

      If the McVeigh case is any guide, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed would be getting executed about now if he had been tried in the regular U.S. legal system.

      •  Doubtful (0+ / 0-)

        Remember that McVeigh actually asked to be executed which greatly sped up the process.  And the judge even had to deliberate on if he was sane because he asked for it, and therefore whether it could be granted or not.  Deathrow inmates get a minimum of 3 appeals I think, which is why it takes 20 yrs and $millions to carry out the sentence.

        So if these guys get in the court system it should take quite a long time.  How many years did it take to get the 20th hijacker tried, and that was for life in prison. 5 or 6 I think.

        •  Believe appeals would have been dismissed quickly (0+ / 0-)

          KSM hasn't exactly been trying to deny his guilt and may well have welcomed his chance at martyrdom.

          I'm not sure it would make a big difference in how long it would take to convict, and likely execute, him.

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site