No, it's not all sunshine and flowers.
Readers, meet Mike Daisey. Mike's a live performer, a monologuist. He travels around, I guess, with his show, where he sits onstage and interacts with the audience. He does use the F-word. He does cover some racy subjects. He's open about it, and so is the box office when you call to get your tickets.
So Mike is doing his show one night, when a group of people get up and start walking out. One of them comes onstage and dumps water all over his handwritten notes--the only set of notes for the show, things Mike has put his blood and love and guts into. His ART, for Chrissake.
And Mr. Mike Daisey reacts with grace under pressure. He invites the people to stay and talk about what they find offensive, to interact with him about the show, to explain why they've just assaulted him. None of them has the courage to do so. They slink away silently, like thieves in the night.
What does an artist do? Just what Mike does.
He goes on with the show. He just picks up, interacts with the remaining audience, and goes on creating--even though his breath is short and he's visibly shaken. He goes on.
The follow-up to this? The "protesters" were a "Christian group" from a local high school. The audience members who stayed included a group from another high school. Both groups were told what type of show they were coming to see. The group that stayed obviously had no problem.
Afterward, Mike found the "protesters." He virtually had to hunt them down so he could open up a dialogue with them. The administrator for the group kept repeating that they were a "Christian" group and had to "protect" their kids--apparently from the F-word. (Read the follow-up post here.) Mike also talked to the man who poured water on his work. Just wanted to talk to him, like a human being, and hear what the hell was up.
Now I'm going to quote at length from Mike's recounting of that talk.
We have been talking for quite some time, making progress, when I mention offhandedly in response to something that I had been raised Catholic.
At this, he makes this little sound: "oh!" It's a tiny exclamation, upward-inflected. I hear that sound, and my heart sinks.
It's a sound of surprise he makes, and of recognition. Of fellowship. And immediately, everything he says is the same, but it is surrounded with a superstructure of scripture--there are supporting arguments from Jesus, the apostles, the whole nine yards. His cadence and language is entirely different, because now he is drawing on over two thousand years of religious writing to enfold and magnify his arguments.
For the first time in the conversation, in my heart, I am furious.
What was I before that moment? I thought we were trying to speak to one another and I was honest with you--but this is your real face, and I only earn the right to see it if I say the right password and get let into your club.
Who was I before? Was I nobody? Was I simply a liberal, the word with the hook on the end of it? A dirty, pornographic artist? A purveyor of filth?
No. It's worse than that, worse than labels. I know the truth. I was no one. I was no one to you, not a real person at all--I wasn't real when you destroyed my work, and until the moment I said the magic word I wasn't real. When he made that sound, he betrayed his heart and finally spoke the truth, and I could see him fully. Now I know him, and now he has no power over me.
We keep talking, and now that I can see him completely he's just an angry man, angry and impotent. He is sorry, though not so sorry that he sought me out--and when I ask what the people in his group are saying about what happened, he confesses that no one is talking about it.
I ask him to do one thing for me. I ask him to talk to everyone in the group together, parents and students alike, and talk to them about what happened. I do not even ask him to apologize, nor do I dictate what he should say--that's his prerogative. I simply ask that he open the door for the conversation be allowed to happen. I believe in the truth, and I want him to let the group speak its mind to him and to itself. I do not know if he did this--I hope that he did, and I will continue to hope.
We engage in art for so many reasons--to transform the world, to share our experience, to process and make sense of our universe. All of it boils down to one thing: to communicate. To be an artist is to communicate, to find that middle ground, to share an experience with your fellow human being.
Fanatics don't want to communicate. They merely want an Other to define themselves against. All too often that other is an artist, because we're easy targets. We're trying so hard to be inclusive that we're easy marks for those who just want to hurt and exclude.
The "Christian group" didn't want dialogue. They didn't want a conversation, or even understanding, or a platform to share their views. By their fruits shall ye know them--they wished only to destroy. No wonder the man who poured the water feels so threatened, so isolated. The only way he can be forced to view someone else as a human being is if they're from his same little cookie-cutter. He cannot communicate, because he has locked the world out, and his fury points itself toward those who have not.
The audience members who stayed were just as shocked and shaken as Mike. And then, when he got back on the horse--when he suggested restarting the show--they applauded.
They applauded. And well they should. We create art to communicate, and we view/read/listen to art to communicate as well. It is the deepest human hunger. You can have all the wealth in the world, but isolation will eventually drive you mad. Shunning is the most painful punishment, and startlingly effective in nonviolent societies--and sometimes, even in the violent ones.
Ladies and gentlemen, meet Mike Daisey, artist. Few deserve the label more. Congratulations to him for staying clear and calm in the middle of an assault on his very right to be a human being, to communicate. Kudos to him for taking this experience, harsh and hurtful as it was, and transforming it into a moving meditation on the power of art to heal and transform.
Even when fanatics seek to shut it out, art crawls through the cracks. It changes the world. Fascist societies and groups fear art for this reason. Because it is stronger. Because it will eventually win. It might take a while, but art always wins in the end.
For it is the strongest medicine and greatest, highest calling of humanity. Art teaches us to listen, because that's half of communicating. It teaches us to stay serene, because we can transform the world at our leisure. It teaches us there's a better way of dealing with conflict than guns, knives, censorship, and violence.
We make art because we must communicate and share. We have no other choice.
There is no other way.
Note: Thanks to Cavalaxis for the link. Also, his post is cross-posted from my regular blog.