We will look really stupid by flooding this company with emails and you keep the damn tickets. I have seen a reponse to this from you.
If you keep the tickets, JetBlue will be able to use it as rebuttal.
Shred the damn things and send them back.
I have seen post after post of the emails and letters sent to JetBLue. All are worthy of note and many are quite eloquent. The reply to my own email from JetBlue was " they are not withdrawing the tickets".
Do the right thing. Send them back, say we don't want or need them. If you keep them, it will appear that we lack the backbone and are unwilling to stand for principle except verbally. Ten or even more tickets are not worth giving that scum O'Reilly a free shot and a shot with substance for once.