Skip to main content

How could Gov. Sarah Palin have "abused her power" by violating the Alaska Executive Branch Ethics Act," if her firing of Commissioner of Public Safety Walt Monegan was a "proper and lawful exercise of her constitutional and statutory authority"?

Update: upaithric in a comment below puts it this way: "In regards to her actions against Monegan, what she did was legal, but in regards to her actions against trooper Wooten, what she did was illegal."

The first of these is Finding Number One in the Report to the Legislative Council filed today by the independent investigator for the Alaska legislature.  The second is Finding Number Two.

Gotta love the language we lawyers use, dontcha?  I am going to provide some explanation of how both Findings can be issued in the same report.

The keys are the words "abused her power by violating" the ethics laws in her attempts to get Trooper Wooten fired, and the words her "constitutional and statutory authority" in regard to the actual firing of Commissioner Monegan.

She lawfully exercised her authority in terms of the laws setting forth what authority she has, but she violated different laws by acting in a manner that abused her use of power in regard to Trooper Wooten.

To put it another way, the Alaska constitution and statutes allow the Governor to do certain things, such as hire and fire officials at will.  If she engages in illegally unethical behavior, she has still exercised her lawful authority.  A court cannot overturn her actions as unconstitutional or contrary to the statutes setting forth how much authority she has.  

But her exercise of power in an illegally unethical manner is still a violation of law -- a different law.

Think of it this way:  Let's say that you are a major national politician and you have a gambling problem (as some do) and that you use your rich wife's money for your habit, without her knowledge or permission.  Heck, let's even say that you took the money from your kids' school's fund for band uniforms and gambled with it.  

You did not violate any statutory authority related to gambling.  The casino can't say that, as punishment for stealing from the kids (an illegal act) you have to give your winnings back to the casino!  Your punishment for that violation is elsewhere.

You still abused your power (violated the public trust) by acting in an unethical manner -- in fact, in a manner prohibited by law.  It is a question, in part, of where the remedy lies for the stealing of the kids' money in my gambling example, or the abuse of the public trust in the case of Gov. Palin's actual actions.

Page 48 of the Report points out that Alaska's ethics law states:

The legislature reaffirms that each public officer holds office as a public trust, and any effort to benefit a personal or financial interest through official action is a violation of that trust.

After listing 18 "events" of improper behavior by Sarah and Todd Palin, the Report says on page 67 that Gov. Palin "knowingly" engaged in various kinds of improper behavior with regard to Trooper Wooten and therefore "abused her power as Governor" and "violated . . . the Ethics Act."

The Report also said on page 65 that "compliance with the code of ethics is not optional" and that the efforts to benefit her personal interests was a violation of "trust."

On page 71, the Report notes that the Constitution of Alaska allows the Governor to fire the head of any department for "virtually any reason."  It notes that she could have had some reasons in additional to her unethical motives, and that is enough to make the action constitutional.

She did not exceed the constitutional authority of the Governor's Office -- but perhaps even Governor Palin would agree that there are some standards that are even higher than those of a state's constitution.  Those who are religious would even say there are some "laws" that are higher.

The Alaska constitution sets minimal standards -- basically no limits at all -- on the exercise of authority by its Governor.  But abuse of power is still unlawful, in a separate sphere.  

Nobody can undo her action in firing Commissioner Monegan as violating the constitution.  But the people have the power to deny high national office to those engaged in illegal abuses of power.

Wouldn't that be a refreshing change from the past nearly 8 years?

Originally posted to oregondem on Fri Oct 10, 2008 at 07:15 PM PDT.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

ClaudeB, gpclay, paradox, Superskepticalman, JWC, ljb, PLS, SWicklund, Cowalker, scribeboy, Chi, nolalily, tundraman, hester, Rayne, Marie, Oregon Bear, abarefootboy, Mountain Don, Rolfyboy6, Tuffy, Unstable Isotope, whataboutbob, mem from somerville, Paul Rosenberg, WestWind, Bob Love, dengre, lobbygow, scrutinizer, Shockwave, donna in evanston, Wintermute, meg, ssteuer, Midwest Meg, Earwicker23, neverontheright, eeff, Mnemosyne, Bexley Lane, WI Deadhead, frisco, lawnorder, Joe B, zeroooo, mataliandy, givmeliberty, Arthur Dent, Heart of the Rockies, dpc, RubDMC, Gustogirl, concernedamerican, m00nchild, EricS, sponson, indybend, wonkydonkey, mbayrob, understandinglife, Agathena, peace voter, 4thgendem, KMc, stevetat, Glic, gayntom, Malixe, scimitar, khloemi, peraspera, LondonYank, LIMAMA, jukeboxgrad, nargel, CodeTalker, axolotl, redux, FeastOr, scotslass, bwren, jalbert, thingamabob, ctsteve, marysz, Jesterfox, DoctorScience, andysbg, CocoaLove, celticshel, OldYellerDog, dksbook, revsue, click your heels, slackjawedlackey, baad, Braindead, webweaver, mayan, dangoch, hopesprings, annan, danthrax, NYC Sophia, Chicago Lulu, Sycamore, brainwave, mad ramblings of a sane woman, grannyhelen, desiunion, exiledfromTN, NYFM, mcfly, snakelass, rockin in the free world, The Zipper, dnn, beachmom, RebeccaG, lcrp, welshvalleymaid, bobcat, barbwires, walkshills, One bite at a time, bwintx, FlyingToaster, AllisonInSeattle, merryelvis, jforman, smartgo, WisVoter, KayCeSF, TexasLefty, edavis, mdsiamese, realalaskan, jainm, thereisnospoon, gsbadj, TekBoss, environmentalist, Frank Vyan Walton, wolverinethad, kevsterwj, sawgrass727, Gowrie Gal, sxwarren, libnewsie, luvmovies2000, jonathan94002, mrmango, ExStr8, bloomer 101, 3goldens, RKinWV, DianeNYS, bellevie, Ckntfld, masondav2004, baccaruda, CTPatriot, Mad Mom, mjd in florida, laird, grimjc, DocGonzo, citizenx, Valtin, basquebob, Clem Yeobright, sandrad23, Mahler3, Dobber, eru, owlbear1, dansk47, SouthPaul, Pam from Calif, Duval Slugger, jimreyn, Buffalo Girl, sheddhead, MoronMike, nwsound, Phil S 33, lauramp, bmaples, lasky57, jane123, CSPAN Junkie, coal, Big Nit Attack, kitchen table activist, EeDan, sodalis, Silence is Complicity, Rogneid, Shiborg, Ekaterin, proudprogressiveCA, ZinZen, chiefsjen, Land of Enchantment, terjeanderson, hatdog, xaxnar, begone, lcork, MagisterLudi, martini, Shirl In Idaho, SoniaS, snazzzybird, CParis, Keone Michaels, PatsBard, Fasaha, myboo, tung sol, Opakapaka, BlueInARedState, emeraldmaiden, stevedubya, Ellicatt, rl en france, cookseytalbott, victoria2dc, martyc35, Samwoman, robitude, Shakludanto, Im with Rosey, fiddler crabby, Soundpolitic, hideinplainsight, campdurning, SherriG, RockNAwe, tecampbell, cRedd, VegasLiberalStevo, Iranaqamuk, NC Dem, real world chick, bleeding heart, MarciaJ720, sceptical observer, myrealname, ER Doc, Unitary Moonbat, dirtfarmer, llbear, Claremore Logic, vox humana, profh, zeke7237, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, HRs Kevin, zorthron, kurt, liberalpercy, chgobob, AmySmith, Bernie68, duha, Temmoku, markthshark, sasher, Pandoras Box, Aaa T Tudeattack, dunneasley, DBunn, ammasdarling, subav8r, Acee, davewolfusa, DrSteveB, out of left field, Buckeye Hamburger, ibonewits, asilomar, thegools, Old Gardener, Ann Galloway, Wanda517, Cat Whisperer, Loudoun County Dem, dmh44, offgrid, moosely2006, Outrider, Allogenes, FishOutofWater, power2truth, lynmar, la urracca, Blue Waters Run Deep, NCDem Amy, deepeco, londubh, Kyle the Mainer, 99 Percent Pure, jayden, eashep, akdude6016, BlueInKansas, jnhobbs, Moderation, Jack the R, RudiB, NorthlandLiberal, Rumarhazzit, uciguy30, leonard145b, skod, JML9999, BasharH, homerun, sable, FreedomRider, BRRubin, craiger, mall teacher, Empower Ink, my homeo, mcyrhul, Send Rahm a Cheesecake, Niniane, jgilhousen, JDWolverton, tfatha, mistletoe, JayC, AnnieJo, condorcet, Roger Fox, DW Dawg, LightningMan, Hippokleides, OleHippieChick, lamzdotes, dennisk, marchtoimpeach, rikyrah, ReEnergizer, Its any one guess, kjboy27, weddedgay, tofumagoo, royce, hwmnbn, eyesonthestreet, evora, Jake Williams, pickandshovel, Quicksilver2723, Jeff Y, mofembot, Rolling, LCA, luckylizard, GoracleFan, bitchinabluestreak, Uncle Bob, nklein, allie123, dmhlt 66, Scubaval, Reframing the Debate, statsone, Wild Starchild, woodtick, oldliberal, ryangoesboom, Redstateresident, Old Woman, maggiejean, 1BQ, Bule Betawi, multilee, Ran3dy, wtxdem, Neon Vincent, MTmarilyn, Texanomaly, emboyo, litoralis, Steve Everett, Good Hope Road, not a cent, gdwtch52, Discipline28, Jeremy10036, Shhs, happy in MA, fearisthemindkiller, hope4achange, Michael James, banjolele, CanyonWren, be the change you seek, Partisan Progressive, crazyshirley2100, SciVo, cultural worker, rnaworld, EquationDoc, Meng Bomin, Daily Activist, ThompsonLazyBoy, jmknapp53, newyorknewyork, Mercuriousss, smartheart, virginwoolf, Shep001, redtex, mama hearts obama, CaliSista, obiterdictum, dawnt, Hope Monger, papahaha, MooseHB, LFL, Vanadium, kevinpdx, drlevant, IngeniousGirl, Shelley99, Dark UltraValia, IreGyre, bbagley1, transparent, RadioGirl, netgui68, 57andFemale, sumo, ArthurPoet, sherijr, louisev, haremoor, sweetliberty, A Voice, azadmanish, mcnamarm, jan0080, JDog42, MizKit, mel70, RoutineFly, Adept2u, Rian Fike, math4barack, Tricky, Emalene, eva lobach, TenthMuse, RogerDodger, chimaeranyc, Hamlets Father, Colorado Billy, Words In Action, ozarkspark, Julia C, Just Bob, BigVegan, Fairy Tale, ladygreenslippers, dalys, BlckKnght, swaminathan, kydoc, BetMyCitizenship, TruthandTrust, kararay, danbury6112, loper2008, awcomeon, winkster, LSD 25, fedupcitizen, mishte, dragonlilleth, miss SPED, Gramarye, NJpeach, robertacker13, TimRivers, stonepier, brunoboy, BP in NJ, georgia gal, piers, Spruced Alien, TheWesternSun, Big Danny, Obamacrat, proudofAmerica, lolynda, Giles Goat Boy, kemetcc, wvmom, msmo1918, Nestmaster, Ronald Singleterry, trixied13, JJC, henry dribble, RJP9999, puffmeister, deboChicago, Leolady, FightersFate, creamer, NY brit expat, ItsSimpleSimon, Anne933, HartfordTycoon, DeppityBob, jbnatedog, JasperJohns, DrFitz, BlueTesuque, Texnance, korinth34, MsGrin, BlueFranco, Canadian Cooper, Floande, Loose Fur, bottles, kathleen518, leu2500, nosleep4u, AMfromATL, rasfrome, Escapade, slice, lucypdx, NU FAN, CompassionateConservative, sickofcynicism, Bronxcutie, JMA, tuaka1992, batchelorjc, nampa45, minkster, giarcyelsi, HockeyMomToo, bmat, zocar, annominous, Freelance Escapologist, Momeaux, Philly526, evelynevvie, MsDrema, condor95, coquiero, YesBiscuit, Mico0109, Valerie8435, Rock Ape, Justin Grimes, bluebluelady, scifiknitter, henrythefifth, TheBlackendCatfish, AuroraDawn, Terrified Liberal, Daniel Mosher, curthess, Clear Thinker, lmrgreen, Amayi, Ham08, buffalogal55, the national gadfly, AtomikNY, BEM, padremiguel, Chacesnana1, bedwyr, Arkieboy, doug1204, RoughAcres

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site