Skip to main content

Sometimes, oh Lord, there is Justice in judges.

On Monday, the Wall Street Journal ran an editorial on the Minnesota Senate recount -- an editorial so ill-informed, so riddled with stupid errors, that one can only assume that it was written by the Norm Coleman campaign and copied verbatim by a naive WSJ editorial board without the messy red tape of actual, you know, fact-checking. Flinging around words like "strange," "dubious" and even "illegitimate," the WSJ described an entirely fictional spineless Canvassing Board ginned up into a partisan machine by Secretary of State Mark Ritchie. They finished with this hyperbole spin lie:

If the Canvassing Board certifies Mr. Franken as the winner based on the current count, it will be anointing a tainted and undeserving Senator.

Today, the Hon. Edward J. Cleary, Assistant Chief Judge of Minnesota's 6th Judicial District and member of the Minnesota State Canvassing Board, wrote a body-slamming hammerlock of a reply that reads like it came from someone with a more than passing acquaintance to a professional wrestler.

As a subscriber of your newspaper for almost three decades, I don't expect to always agree with your editorial viewpoint. Yet I am nevertheless very disappointed when I read an editorial long on partisan tone and short on accurate reporting.
As a member of the Minnesota State Canvassing Board, appointed pursuant to statute, I have attended all nine Board open meetings held the past seven weeks. I am knowledgeable about the proceedings as well as Minnesota's election laws. Our members (two Supreme Court Justices, two District Court Judges, and Secretary of State Ritchie) came from all political backgrounds, openly expressed our opinions at the meetings, and can hardly be accurately described as "meek", unless you mean "meek" by New York in-your-face standards. Your groundless attack on Secretary Ritchie reflects poorly on the author; Ritchie worked assiduously at avoiding partisanship in these proceedings.
As to the Board as a whole, all of our major votes were unanimous. We consistently followed the law in limiting our involvement to a non-adjudicative role, declining both candidates' attempts to expand our mandate. Further, we painstakingly reviewed each challenged ballot, some more than once, to confirm that we were ruling in a consistent manner.
One can only assume, based on the tone of the editorial, the numerous inaccuracies, and the over-the-top slam at Al Franken ("tainted and undeserving?") that had Norm Coleman come out on top in this recount, the members of the Board would have been praised as "strong-willed, intelligent, and perceptive."
We won't hold our breath waiting for that editorial to appear.

[UPDATE: More explicit kudos to Dave Brauer at the irreplaceable MinnPost for scooping this nugget. Link is above. And, yes, thanks Kossacks for the reclist!]

Over at fivethirtyeight, Nate Silver has already eviscerated factual "basis" of the WSJ editorial like a pathologist in the autopsy room.

And finally, even Minnesota's solidly GOP Powerline took the WSJ to the woodshed:

The Board of Canvassers that was convened to preside over the recount and rule on challenged ballots conducted itself honorably under difficult circumstances. ... I have known Chief Justice Magnuson professionally more than 25 years. Justice Anderson was my law school classmate and is a friend. In my view, they are two of the best judges serving in the Minnesota courts. Period.

There was no noticeable partisan division among the board. Minnesotans are justifiably proud of the transparency and fairness of their work. I reject any imputation of misconduct to the board such as is implicit in the Journal editorial.

Originally posted to The Numerate Historian on Wed Jan 07, 2009 at 01:56 PM PST.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

MercuryX23, dirigo, Paolo, wozzle, Alumbrados, Ed in Montana, Susan S, JWC, buffalo soldier, KeithH, Terri, underwhelm, Angelfan, Ducktape, PLS, jab, Bill in Portland Maine, Sean Robertson, fcvaguy, jazzmaniac, Chi, Phoenix Woman, EB4Dean, Sally in SF, murphy, lanshark, BrooklynJohnny, alyosha, teacherken, laurak, kate mckinnon, Timaeus, ORDem, askew, Trendar, Better Days, bball, gogol, Liberal Thinking, moon in the house of moe, daninoah, mickT, abarefootboy, Mountain Don, mndan, TrueBlueMajority, decafdyke, AdmiralNaismith, Unstable Isotope, nicolemm, saraswati, melvynny, ScientistMom in NY, mattman, janinsanfran, Bob Love, newjeffct, greenbird, tnichlsn, bosdcla14, dengre, tommurphy, Shockwave, byteb, Sherri in TX, Wintermute, tacet, kpardue, Arlyn, Blue Shark, gaff98, nemoplanetia, John Campanelli, eeff, Mnemosyne, TX Unmuzzled, route66, figdish, WI Deadhead, frisco, ZAPatty, marjo, sobermom, TexasLiberal, lilorphant, lzachary, SallyCat, Bob Friend, FyodorFish, BenGoshi, object16, pollyusa, grndrush, carrieboberry, bumblebums, zeroooo, mataliandy, exNYinTX, Arthur Dent, Creosote, redtravelmaster, Heart of the Rockies, Plan9, sardonyx, kissfan, dpc, eyeswideopen, EvieCZ, Justina, bronte17, 88kathy, conchita, medaka, EricS, jfeichter, powerplay40, indybend, mentaldebris, wonkydonkey, Cassandra77, elveta, rhp, Prairie Logic, ask, peace voter, KMc, Joon, PBnJ, ChicagoCillen, ksh01, Scoopster, Porfiry, tmmike, boilerman10, mkfarkus, pattisigh, buckhorn okie, phild1976, vmibran, marchmoon, barath, farmerhunt, chechecule, jeff06dem, altoid, javelina, pollbuster, denig, Ignacio Magaloni, murphsurf, sgilman, skertso, oceanspray, superba, MJB, BruinKid, DiMe, paprog, itskevin, not lois, oceanview, MadEye, Nate Roberts, navajo, antirove, Alna Dem, admiralh, CocoaLove, dksbook, Brit, Redfire, worldwideellen, JimDev, SneakySnu, Braindead, kharma, Dube, psnyder, Alizaryn, nancelot, danthrax, sockpuppet, marko, Dallasdoc, Miss Jones, pat bunny, crkrjx, QuarterHorseDem, MTgirl, grannyhelen, ssundstoel, Nina, hoolia, jaywillie, desmoinesdem, wdrath, NYFM, NYBri, Penny Century, attydave, defluxion10, Catte Nappe, rockhound, whyvee, puffin6092, razajac, rlharry, lcrp, MagentaMN, Democratic Hawk, dkmich, walkshills, outragedinSF, Oaktown Girl, Panda, Exurban Mom, AllisonInSeattle, peterj911, jesses, WV Democrat, Curt Matlock, randallt, paisa, KayCeSF, tomjones, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, Wife of Bath, SanDiegoDem, poemworld, xyz, mdsiamese, vacantlook, slapshoe, furi kuri, boran2, Timroff, murrayewv, Armand451, BDA in VA, Gowrie Gal, 2d, jordans11, luvmovies2000, rapala, nailbender, tardcat, gradinski chai, vcmvo2, madaprn, jonathan94002, chumley, bloomer 101, Bluesee, radarlady, Tinfoil Hat, Kewalo, IamtheReason, powwow500, bellevie, UFOH1, m16eib, Five of Diamonds, Othniel, baccaruda, Russron, revbludge, LisaZ, subtropolis, Halcyon, PBen, Alice Venturi, kosi revaya, stitchmd, Ajax the Greater, drewfromct, TigerMom, YucatanMan, Dobber, Gary Norton, Claybow, reflectionsv37, Bouwerie Boy, boofdah, eru, Jules Beaujolais, Mz Kleen, lennysfo, owlbear1, GUGA, cfk, Viceroy, LNK, SaraBeth, Pam from Calif, kmras, jorndorff, Jaime Frontero, pandawoman, EdlinUser, uato carabau, jimreyn, Buffalo Girl, where4art, Inland, jcitybone, lasky57, sunbro, Cecile, phaedras, kaliope, Cyber Kat, techno, nyseer, Marcus Junius Brutus, serrano, zinger99, sodalis, deepsouthdoug, dsteffen, Rogneid, playtonjr, Lindy, hcc in VA, sgary, JanF, tigerdog, Alan Arizona, Land of Enchantment, zozie, kathny, simplicio, fhcec, xaxnar, coffeeinamrica, Wayneman, begone, lcork, skywriter, alrdouglas, SoulCatcher, third Party please, occams hatchet, kovie, abundibot, hlee1169, SmplieSum1, danmac, MissInformation, twoducks, mcronan, Do Tell, tarheelblue, Keone Michaels, jsamuel, Pinko Elephant, myboo, sherlyle, RustyBrown, Junkyard Dem, ferallike, BlueInARedState, Themistoclea, hungrycoyote, DC Scott, Kimball Cross, Ellicatt, hamiltonk, Gorette, t minnow, rl en france, liberalconservative, seefleur, mooshter, victoria2dc, koNko, Samwoman, ccmask, arlene, mcartri, madcitymelvin, SarekOfVulcan, campdurning, SherriG, bren, NBBooks, triv33, TalkieToaster, tecampbell, birdbrain64, MJ via Chicago, global citizen, StrayCat, gpoutney, nonnie9999, gooderservice, imabluemerkin, real world chick, JVolvo, Sagebrush Bob, CTLiberal, Preston S, MarciaJ720, ER Doc, Unitary Moonbat, Jax, doinaheckuvanutjob, bonesy, Pilgrim X, llbear, SingerInTheChoir, Cenobyte, rage, Timothy J, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, va dare, dhomyak, BB10, fiddlingnero, The Lighthouse Keeper, means are the ends, frankzappatista, RantNRaven, rjbeach2003, airmarc, PhilW, bstotts, dochackenbush, christomento, AllanTBG, markthshark, Little, illusionmajik, Aaa T Tudeattack, NonnyO, AntKat, ammasdarling, lams712, ccyd, BoyBlue, pgm 01, YoyogiBear, out of left field, gwriter, asilomar, Ken in MN, Fredly, sccs, beneldon, wa ma, Haningchadus14, Ann Galloway, Mom to Miss M, Loudoun County Dem, oscarsmom, blue armadillo, Cottagerose, FWIW, california keefer, moodyinsavannah, jetskreemr, gtghawaii, Searching for Truth, moosely2006, edsbrooklyn, FishOutofWater, la urracca, yowsta, HeartlandLiberal, Jimdotz, mommyof3, sfbob, joyful, londubh, Ninepatch, MonsterSound, FischFry, entlord1, davehouck, Strabo, bnasley, gatorbot, Kyle the Mainer, Seneca Doane, artisan, jayden, jedennis, vbdietz, cyncynical, DemMarineVet, jnhobbs, Bridge Master, Jack the R, Wreck Smurfy, richBixby, cececville, Rumarhazzit, christianlsv, Dar Nirron, Brahman Colorado, madgranny, kubrick2008, wmholt, Aynsley, JML9999, skaye19, Zydekos, homerun, rf7777, lorac18nc, Bikemom, TomP, Empower Ink, gizmo59, rmonroe, Send Rahm a Cheesecake, BustaVessel, sand805, JDWolverton, eparrot, Dem in the heart of Texas, kkmama, rogerdaddy, gundyj, mconvente, ratador, Hippokleides, TomY, RickMassimo, oolali, califdem, poligirl, geez53, last starfighter, dave1042, skohayes, CDH in Brooklyn, OutCarolineStreet, Rick Winrod, Sharon Wraight, Mother of Zeus, Its any one guess, jakebob, baudelairien, kjboy27, Lujane, tofumagoo, royce, boatjones, NMLib, evora, geomoo, icebergslim, Jake Williams, pickandshovel, MsWings, Quicksilver2723, Jeff Y, rubine, mofembot, noddem, Pogyak, Gemina13, dagnabbit, mspt, william f harrison, luckylizard, CeeusBeeus, xysea, BYw, eddienutzak, Tross, stillwaters, dont think, Guadalupe59, newton123, cafreema, Yoshi En Son, dmhlt 66, Simply Agrestic, princess k, bluegrass50, legendmn, 4km, ryangoesboom, Fiddlegirl, maggiejean, SciMathGuy, tabby, hardtoport, Bule Betawi, multilee, Rhysling, McGahee220, Ripeness Is All, number nine dream, Fonsia, wtxdem, Texanomaly, WSComn, ARS, emboyo, Mech0T1, Discipline28, holger smed, sunhaws, eroded47095, jaf49, CanyonWren, Yerba Buena, Inky99, eco d, imchange, janmtairy, theworksanddays, Partisan Progressive, ScientistSteve, h bridges, velvet blasphemy, bigmikek7, math monkey, rini6, Daily Activist, Robert Sandy, Mercuriousss, dRefractor, Virginian in Spain, followyourbliss, manucpa, DHinIA, AvoMonster, mksutherland, ZilV, MySobriquet, Vanadium, obscuresportsquarterly, hyper, kevinpdx, IngeniousGirl, IreGyre, edgeways, elropsych, Lava20, 57andFemale, Houston Gardener, D Wreck, fitz2, nancat357, ravenlore, xylem, Wisteacher, Emalene, RogerDodger, SweetMartha, Cleopatra, Larsstephens, ljfxiki, lompe, cezariusz, Lazar, CalGal47, ladygreenslippers, Carl Brutanananadilewski, niaman, oohdoiloveyou, CajunBoyLgb, awcomeon, Jampacked, pyegar, p gorden lippy, GBC, flitedocnm, Obamican08, VenturaProgressive, LaughingPlanet, The Jester, Gangster Octopus, skeezixwolfnagle, robertacker13, imamish, dditt, Voodoo king, Blue Blood, blueingreen, blueyescryinintherain, leftywright, PurpleMyst, MarkMarvin, seanwhit, cmolson63, jdw112, Indie Tarheel, fidellio, on board 47, klompendanser, chrome327, Crabby Abbey, wvmom, JellyBearDemMom, freeport beach PA, trixied13, rkthomas, JJC, ATFILLINOIS, Dexter, Nurse Jeckell, cordgrass, MoshebenAvraham, ctlrick, madeup64, pixxer, HartfordTycoon, Puddytat, rfall, aggie98, NYWheeler, halef, kalika, orca43, Hope Reborn, itswhatson, rja, nirbama, Im nonpartisan, dclarke, MsGrin, BlueFranco, Toon, Hoosierdaddio, Floande, bottles, josebrwn, DirkFunk, zora129, alexa100, Actbriniel, Vega, anaxiamander, newusername, NellaSelim, nyacker, ribofunk, Pakalolo, nampa45, Colorado is the Shiznit, annominous, modalrealist, Olon, wahine, curthess, Laurdet, ardyess, the national gadfly, speet, kevin k, trs, sallym, blueinmn, miranda2060, Victory of Renegades, Jed Lewison, Haf2Read, semctydem, zukesgirl64, Cinnamon Rollover, buddingactivist, incognita, mniowan, KVoimakas, Laurie Gator, sjr1, CKendall, arcticshadow, terabthia2, jgnyc, enhydra lutris

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site