Skip to main content

   Remember how crooked accountants like Arthur Anderson helped create the Enron disaster? Well the credit rating oligopoly of the Big Three (Moody’s, Fitch and Standard & Poor’s) is doing almost the same thing, and Senator Al Franken wants to put a stop to it.

    As Senator Franken told ABC news

    "If a failing student paid their teacher to turn their F into an A, everyone would agree that what the teacher had done was unethical ... But right now, investors are being sold a phony bill of goods. We need to protect consumers from the pay-to-play system that rewards Wall Street players at the expense of Main Street."

h/t to Kossack DDay at

   Al Franken has an Amendment to the Wall St reform bill bring this to an end.

More below the fold


   You see, what Arthur Anderson was to Enron, the Big Three credit rating agencies are to the Too Big To Fail banks. The only way Arthur Anderson could get Enron's business was by knowingly and fraudulently cooking their books. The only way the Big Three crooked credit rating agencies can get business from TBTF banks is by knowingly and fraudulently giving them good ratings, even when they are failing. That is their profit motive, to cook the books.

    Sen. Franken proposed an amendment to create a Credit Rating Agency Board, supervised by the Securities and Exchange Commission, which would assign credit rating agencies to provide initial ratings in order to reduce conflicts of interest. This would increase competition by enabling smaller credit rating agencies to finally have an opportunity to compete against the largest three agencies.

   Watch Senator Franken explain the whole thing with political cartoons! (Presumably for those slower, Conservative Senators)

    Here’s what the amendment would do. It would allow the SEC to set up a self-regulatory organization (that is, one not created by Congress) called the Credit Rating Agency Board. The CRAB, made up of investors as well as independent regulators, would then create a roster of qualified rating agencies, and select a method of assigning initial ratings on securities to those agencies. The amendment would encourage randomization but not mandate it. Staffers explained to me that a literal randomization would swamp the smaller rating agencies, who wouldn’t be able to handle the workload, relative to the big three of Moody’s, Fitch and Standard & Poor’s. The rating issuance would have to account for the performance of the rating agencies, and the board would not know which agency the issuer preferred.

    Issuers could then go out and get a secondary rating after this initial rating, but the initial rating would stay on the record of the security. Franken staffers believed this would prevent deals where the issuing bank haggles with a rating agency for a better rating, and would lead to more accurate results, even in the secondary ratings, since a variance between that and the initial rating would raise eyebrows.

   So here is the rub; if you miss a single payment on your credit card your credit rating takes a huge hit, but if the bank that owns your credit card is thisclose to failing, they get a Triple A rating. Why? Because they provide the credit ratings agencies with millions and billions of profit and you do not.

   In a normal, sane world, this is called fraud, and I am glad to know that I am not the only one calling it that.

Big three rating agencies being sued for negligence, fraud and deceit

    Do you remember the Lehman Bankruptcy? Well it seems thatRon Grassi is suing the three credit rating agencies for negligence, fraud and deceit. Mr. Grassi invested $40,000 in Lehman bonds because they had an A rating. With this small but significant lawsuit Grassi could blow the lid off the bogus ratings given out by rating agencies over the past several years. Mr. Grassi feels that more than anything else, the false ratings were the cause of the financial meltdown.

    Practically everyone in the financial industry depends on the big three: Fitch Rating, Moody's Corp (NYSE: MCO) and Standard and Poor's for making their financial decisions. This includes mutual funds, hedge funds, insurance companies and even the Federal Reserve. Credit agencies helped create $3.2 trillion of subprime mortgages.

    In the midst of all the chaos, profit margins for the rating agencies rose sharply. Moody's profit margins were up 52% and they reported a profit of $1.76 billion, and made huge profits even during the collapse of 2008.

Bold text added by the diarist

   Yeah, that's the ticket. Fraud, deceit and negligence. That sums up perfectly what the Credit rating oligopoly has been up to.

Here is Senator Franken's entire floor speech from Thursday when he first proposed his Amendment to the current Wall St reform bill.

    Senator Franken is spot on with his assessment of the crooked credit ratings agencies. Over in Europe, similar regulations and competition are being proposed for the oligopoly of credit ratings agencies.

   Some European officials are calling for curbs on rating agencies like Standard & Poor's, Moody's Corp. and Fitch Ratings. They argue that conflicts of interest and bad information make the agencies' assessments unreliable, even dangerous.

   Germany's foreign minister went so far Thursday as to suggest that the European Union should create its own rating agency. He spoke after downgrades of Greece and Portugal roiled financial markets and stoked fears that Europe's debt crisis was spreading.

    How ratings agencies are paid is also coming under scrutiny. The money they earn comes from the institutions whose products and debt they rate – a point of contention in the U.S. and Europe. At a hearing last week on the agencies' role in the financial crisis, U.S. Sen. Carl Levin called that pay system an "inherent conflict of interest."

Bold text added by the diarist

   I much prefer Senator Franken's idea for an independent credit rating panel that would povide non profit competition and unbiased credit ratings over the European idea for an EU controlled agency, as an EU controlled organization would be just as prone to bias in favor of European controlled banks as a private credit ratings agency is biased towards the private Too Big To Fail banks that provides them a profit, but that is just my opinion, and I tend to err in favor of competition, but I am no expert, and if someone knows more on the subject than I do I would be glad to hear their ideas.

    But one thing I do know is that the Oligopolies that dominate so many of America's industries are strangling the majority of Americans with their fraud, deceit and negligence. The fraud in this scheme works like this, the credit raters give good ratings no matter how crappy the credit of the big banks are, because they are their clients and that is how they make their money. This leads investors to believe they are making a good bet, when they are really betting on a lemon with a new paint job. I call that fraud, but on Wall St it is called business as usual, and it has to end.

    And though I do not trust the Senate anymore than I'd trust a shark cage made of salami, I applaud the efforts to reign in the Oligopolies made by those stalwart Progressives such as Al Franken, Sherrod Brown and Bernie Sanders. It is efforts such as theirs that give me hope.

    When I hear Corporatist Conservatives shriek about a Guvmint takeovah I know what the reality is, it is the Corporate takeover of everything they can get their hands on. Why? Money!

    So let's fight back, like Senator Al Franken and others are doing. If not now, when?

    If you like my articles and want to support Progressive primary and general election candidates, join PeanutButterPAC, the PAC that fights back!

    Vote for me to get a DFA Netroots Nation scholarship!

    You can follow me on Twitter at @JesseLaGreca

Crossposted at

Originally posted to MinistryOfTruth on Sat May 08, 2010 at 12:22 PM PDT.


What is the best word to describe what the Credit Ratings Agencies have been doing?

51%268 votes
4%21 votes
2%13 votes
2%15 votes
37%198 votes
1%7 votes

| 522 votes | Vote | Results

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Tookish, JekyllnHyde, Alumbrados, Angie in WA State, JWC, MS, TXdem, Finn, Phoenix Woman, Odysseus, murphy, gogol, abarefootboy, artr2, Unstable Isotope, RunawayRose, wytcld, Emerson, tommurphy, meg, Arlyn, LEP, eeff, Mnemosyne, TX Unmuzzled, LeftHandedMan, ZAPatty, gjohnsit, SallyCat, Creosote, Doctor Who, RumsfeldResign, opinionated, TheMomCat, Justina, bronte17, cyberKosFan, Einsteinia, wonkydonkey, Doc Allen, understandinglife, DaleA, KMc, PBnJ, mkfarkus, barath, Ignacio Magaloni, nargel, Miss Blue, dchill, jalbert, frightwig, antirove, sidnora, wader, Texknight, NMRed, tidalwave1, psnyder, danthrax, TiaRachel, churchylafemme, BMarshall, AbsurdEyes, lcrp, 2dot, LR Frederick, dkmich, econlibVA, AllisonInSeattle, Curt Matlock, WisVoter, activated, lyvwyr101, ganymeade, ck4829, Limelite, Gowrie Gal, rapala, leolabeth, bloomer 101, Tarindel, ManOnTheBench, Kewalo, NoMoreLies, Ckntfld, enough, LarisaW, arnott, irate, sc kitty, Flint, run around, panicbean, dewtx, Brooke In Seattle, YucatanMan, Dobber, owlbear1, Annalize5, Pam from Calif, jimstaro, jimreyn, where4art, ladybug53, Overseas, Rex Freedom, Sandino, Southside, kaliope, Isara, PinHole, AnotherMassachusettsLiberal, serrano, FindingMyVoice, deepsouthdoug, Cory Bantic, Rogneid, Ekaterin, bently, Jim P, reddbierd, Mother Mags, Denny in Seattle, third Party please, irishwitch, Kingsmeg, sherlyle, 417els, edwardssl, tobendaro, Themistoclea, rl en france, raptavio, seefleur, sabredance, KenBee, carolita, 4Freedom, Francine Shacter, gpoutney, The Hindsight Times, Glorfindel, gooderservice, gatorcog, imabluemerkin, real world chick, NearlyNormal, bleeding heart, el cid, sceptical observer, doinaheckuvanutjob, middleagedhousewife, quantumspin, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, goinsouth, kurt, revgerry, shaharazade, Hedwig, Land of Lincoln Dem, Little, AntKat, ladypockt, ammasdarling, bigchin, One Pissed Off Liberal, tonyfv, marykk, Loudoun County Dem, byDesign, DocbytheBay, WeBetterWinThisTime, Outrider, Mary Mike, jeanette0605, ezdidit, deepeco, bnasley, kingyouth, getlost, jedennis, Dar Nirron, Brahman Colorado, M Sullivan, JML9999, homerun, Spedwybabs, South Park Democrat, Terra Mystica, VA Breeze, commonweal, FirstValuesThenIssues, revm3up, mconvente, JaxDem, DraftChickenHawks, rontun, scooter in brooklyn, ScottyUrb, elwior, filby, ajr111240, minerva1157, jamess, monkeybrainpolitics, Happy Days, Cassandra Waites, Jake Williams, pickandshovel, bluesheep, Jeff Y, Ladyhawk, mofembot, Gemina13, petulans, True Independent, Parthenia, eddienutzak, allie123, magicsister, Mike Taylor, greenpunx, papicek, statsone, 207wickedgood, clent, SciMathGuy, Ran3dy, driftwood, MTmarilyn, litoralis, snackdoodle, Stranded Wind, Partisan Progressive, ScientistSteve, bigmikek7, mkor7, rini6, JesseCW, DefendOurConstitution, glassbeadgame, johnbrown, UnaSpenser, obiterdictum, TheOpinionGuy, ZilV, Corneliusmingus, kevinpdx, CityLightsLover, 57andFemale, vcthree, Livvy5, Black Kos, SweetMartha, RhymesWithUrple, henlesloop, awcomeon, NMDad, Tx LIberal, pyegar, flitedocnm, alpolitics, candysroom, fidellio, mollyk, Tcoopy, Polly Syllabic, trixied13, Eddie L, missississy, elginblt, ItsSimpleSimon, JasperJohns, ClearBuzz, NYWheeler, sharonsz, halef, JRandomPoster, Betty Pinson, Unenergy, dclarke, ericlewis0, quityurkidding, Dems in 08, nosleep4u, TigerStar337, alexa100, HylasBrook, slice, Onomastic, Colorado is the Shiznit, annominous, nicethugbert, OldGrammy, BlueJessamine, ontheleftcoast, the national gadfly, FarWestGirl, Situational Lefty, Liberal OC Woman, Tim McMahon, princesspat, thethinveil, PedalingPete, marleycat, zukesgirl64, majii, Cinnamon Rollover, thomask, Coastrange, beka, gokinsmen, MRA NY, Vtdblue, whoknu, MuskokaGord, jediwashuu, zapus, Safina, Aquagranny911, randomfacts, Wom Bat, debit, SteelerGrrl, Ezekial 23 20, leftykook, thejoshuablog, aerie star, jaebone, MichaelNY, James Philip Pratt, DawnN, Nena20409, James Robinson, KiB, OHknighty, cwsmoke, IndieGuy, delmardougster, NWIA Granny, Eric Nelson, J Brunner Fan, DarkWater, AreDeutz, Socratic Method, HoofheartedBC, Lovepolitics2008, Othniel Kenaz

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site