Skip to main content

Bill Moyers wants you to read John Geyman’s "HIJACKED: The Road to Single Payer in the Aftermath of Stolen Health Care Reform"

"You think the battle for real health care reform is over? John Geyman says ‘Not on your life!’ And, by the way, your life is what’s at stake. This former Republican country doctor and long-time respected scholar, editor, and advocate for reform that puts the patient, not the industry, first, has issued an informed, convincing, and passionate account of why the battle has just begun, and how we, the people, can win."

Below and over the next several days, I will re-posting (with permission from Dr. Geyman), and with some additional commentary of my own, excerpts from the book that have previously run at the PNHP blog and over at HuffPo.

These are both a bit wonky, insofar as they are policy analysis, not immdedate current event partisan politics. And they are admittedly single-issue and specifically single payer.

On the one hand, I do believe that there are some good things in the health reform bill as it passed, particularly the expansion of Medicaid, expansion of Community Health Centers and National Health Service Corps, and other parts of the safety net. And I do acknoweldge those who feel that "health reform" has been done, and it is time to move on to other battles.


You still can't make money by insuring sick people.

This is the basic economic fact that will make the current reform a failure in due course. And it is why single payer, not the current reform nor the so-called public option, will ultimately be needed as a matter of policy.

It is important for everybody to realize that the reform we got was NOT progressive reform.  As costs continue to escalate, and too many people are still uninsured and under-insured, there will be a fork in the road. Corporatists, conservatives, free market fundamentalists, and of course Republicans, will argue that this is because the current reform was too much big government interference.  In reality it will be because the reform was a near total capitulation to the for-profit powers-that-be. Rather too much government, it was way too little.  We need to be prepared to make that argument, starting yesterday.

PNHP and other single payer advocates have been there all all along. Shunted aside by Clinton in 1992, we were still there doing the grassroots work work when others fled after 1994.  I have been making the policy case for single payer here at DailyKos since 2006, and John explained why propping up the insurance companies with mandates was a bad idea in 2009.  

We will still be here tomorrow.

Hijacked—Stolen Health Care Reform: Why Health Care Costs Will Not Be Contained

by John Geyman MD

The passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (PPACA), our new health care legislation, in March was hailed by its supporters as an historic event of the magnitude of Social Security and Medicare. But four months later, it remains controversial, with repeated polls showing three large groups of divisive opinion, including those who would work to repeal it and others who believe that it will make no difference. The Democrats have launched a $125 million PR campaign to defend the new law amidst growing signs that many Democrats facing re-election are failing to get political traction on the issue. (1) (Allen, M. Dems launch $125 M health campaign. Politico, June 7, 2010)

We are being advised by many to "wait and see" how this complex new bill plays out over the next five to ten years, but we can already know what its outcomes will be. More than 30 years of health policy science, including documentation of the repeated failures of incremental changes built into the new law, together with well-entrenched trends in our market-based system, allow us to project its outcomes with confidence. For this legislation has been molded and crafted by the political power and money of corporate stakeholders in the medical-industrial complex.

Five previous posts in 2009 described the uneasy "alliance" of the five biggest players—the insurance industry, the drug industry, the hospital industry, business and organized medicine. They will do just fine with the new law at the expense of patients, families and Main Street.

Health care "reform" this time around was intended to address these four basic system problems: (1) containing health care costs, (2) making health care more affordable, (3) increasing access to care, and (4) improving the quality of care. This post introduces a series of five that will examine how well the PPACA will do on each of these four goals, followed by an overall assessment of the law. These posts will draw in part from my new book Hijacked: The Road to Single Payer in the Aftermath of Stolen Health Care Reform


These are some of the many reasons that we can already conclude that health care costs will continue to run out of control at rates far exceeding the costs of living and median household incomes.

•  No price controls. Wall Street has already factored in rapid expansion of markets for drugs, medical devices and other services in a system of expanded access. There is also a long line forming of providers of information technology and administrative services that will exploit the complex implementation of this law.

•  No bulk purchasing. The PPACA has prohibited the government from negotiating the prices of prescription drugs and retains a ban on importation of drugs from Canada and other countries.

•  Lack of control over perverse incentives that drive increased volume of services. These in turn are driven by retention of fee-for-service (FFS) reimbursement that encourages physicians and other providers to offer more services than are medically appropriate or necessary.

•  No effective mechanism to rein in marginal or ineffective technologies. Coverage policies for new drugs and medical devices are still lax and not subject to rigorous evidence-based criteria for either efficacy or cost-effectiveness. Although the PPACA does call for a Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, its role is already neutered by not having the power to mandate or even endorse coverage or reimbursement rules for any particular treatment. (2) (Kaiser Health News staff. True or false: Seven concerns about the new health law, March 31, 2010)

•  The dominant business model of health care prevails, with many facilities and services remaining for-profit and investor-owned and with an ongoing trend for increasing consolidation within industries.

•  The PPACA has grandfathered-in specialty hospitals, typically physician-owned facilities that focus on well-reimbursed procedures in such areas as cardiology and orthopedics, whereby physicians can "triple dip", earning high incomes as providers, owners and investors.

•  More preventive services will further fuel health care inflation. While the PPACA does provide new coverage for many preventive services, this will lead to increased costs due to additional diagnostic and treatment services engendered. (3) (Russell, L. Preventing chronic disease: An important investment, but don’t count on cost savings. Health Affairs 28 (1): 42-5, 2009)

•  Private insurers can’t contain health care costs, even where they have dominant market power. A 2009 report by the Congressional Research Service, The Market Structure of the Health Insurance Industry, concludes that "The exercise of market power by firms in concentrated markets generally leads to higher prices and reduced output—high premiums and limited access to health
insurance—combined with high profits." (4) (Austin, DA, Hungerford, TL. The Market Structure of the Health Insurance Industry. Washington, D.C. Congressional Research Service, November 17, 2009)

• There are no controls over premium rate increases by insurers. Despite the outcry by government officials, annual premium rates are escalating at rates up to 56 percent (5) (Johnson, A. Fight over health-care premiums heats up. Wall Street Journal, February 19, 2010: A6), and there is no end in sight for continued exorbitant rate increases. Insurers will continue to game the system by extracting
maximal profits and offering reduced coverage with actuarial values (the amounts insurers actually pay in coverage) as low as 60 or 70 percent.

•  National health care spending will grow unabated despite the passage of PPACA. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) projects that overall national health expenditures (NHE) will increase from its present 17 percent of GDP to 21 percent in 2019, a total of $4.470 trillion. (6) (Foster, RS. Office of the Actuary. Estimated financial effects of the "Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act," as Amended. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, April 22, 2010)

These well-documented trends leave no room to think that health care "reform" will have any chance to contain health care costs. Instead, health care inflation will be exacerbated by all the new incentives and inefficiencies in the new "system". In our next post we will examine the impact of these trends on affordability of health care.

By the way, I have no financial interest in Dr. Geyman's book. I am just a fan. John Geyman, M.D., is one of the leading academic family medicine doctors in the country, with many professional journal publications and is author several leading texbooks in family medicne, rural medicine and evidenced-based medicine; he is former chairperson and now professor emeritus at the University of Washignton (arguably the best department of Family Medicine in the country when he was Chair), former editor of the Journal of the American Board of Family Practice. As the New England Journal of Medicine wrote, "Geyman's literary voice arises from his unusual professional and political trajectories: from country doctor to academic department chair and prominent journal editor, and from longtime Republican to president of Physicians for a National Health Program...a passionate advocate and scholar."

Really, if you have a serious interest in health care reform you should look at his books.

I'll be back with more excerpts over the next several days.

Originally posted to DrSteveB on Mon Aug 30, 2010 at 02:20 PM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Meteor Blades, jbou, bink, Renee, gpclay, Tookish, JekyllnHyde, Alumbrados, Superskepticalman, Ed in Montana, Angie in WA State, cslewis, Mimikatz, vicki, Marek, coral, LeislerNYC, Chi, catdevotee, Odysseus, jotter, Rayne, SarahLee, alyosha, teacherken, slinkerwink, El Zmuenga, Trendar, gustafgrapple, Liberal Thinking, GreenSooner, Nina Katarina, Gooserock, pHunbalanced, Powered Grace, saraswati, emal, janinsanfran, sacrelicious, Emerson, karlpk, tommurphy, musicalhair, Shockwave, Pescadero Bill, maracucho, billlaurelMD, Blue Shark, Aspe4, Earwicker23, akeitz, celdd, dkistner, xynz, azale, TarheelDem, RFK Lives, Zach in Phoenix, shpilk, Creosote, Doctor Who, Heart of the Rockies, erinmblair, opinionated, bronte17, Zinman, TracieLynn, Nellcote, Einsteinia, wonkydonkey, dionys1, nyceve, Agathena, CoolOnion, weirdscenes, bluesteel, Pithy Cherub, chuckvw, cosmic debris, gayntom, mkfarkus, rickpickett, Aquarius40, JuliaAnn, drsmith131, Larry Bailey, Boston to Salem, Miss Blue, ornerydad, Boxers, Nate Roberts, ctsteve, Jesterfox, Iberian, enough already, splashy, bustacap, nuttymango, Eddie C, wader, Braindead, Eric Blair, Alizaryn, minorityusa, danthrax, TexDem, Dallasdoc, businessdem, CitizenOfEarth, 2laneIA, MA Liberal, gmb, TiaRachel, gerrilea, GrainofSand, cosette, peternight, churchylafemme, texasmom, BMarshall, DSC on the Plateau, dwahzon, 42, Chirons apprentice, On The Bus, betson08, hazzcon, puffin6092, RebeccaG, lcrp, 313to212, LR Frederick, Chun Yang, lahke, walkshills, Oaktown Girl, Bendra, ralphbon, zett, ybruti, WV Democrat, side pocket, Silverbird, Kitsap River, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, Wife of Bath, Marianne Benz, jcrit, poemworld, TexasLefty, lyvwyr101, vacantlook, rambler american, Daddy Bartholomew, Timroff, greeseyparrot, Gowrie Gal, Big Tex, rapala, nailbender, nehark, madaprn, joanneleon, Recovering Southern Baptist, bloomer 101, Bluesee, marina, 3goldens, Kewalo, NoMoreLies, denise b, Ckntfld, jfdunphy, caul, LarisaW, jarneys dad, JanetT in MD, CTPatriot, disrael, democracy inaction, OpherGopher, irate, Technowitch, Erik the Red, PBen, Militarytracy, Jersey Girl, Flint, run around, panicbean, truong son traveler, RequestedUsername, TN yellow dog, drewfromct, chidmf, YucatanMan, trinityfly, Laurence Lewis, reflectionsv37, ratzo, eru, lennysfo, GUGA, Annalize5, Chaoslillith, LNK, Frank Palmer, truebeliever, Mr X, where4art, ladybug53, Burned, bluemanredtex, jane123, AnotherMassachusettsLiberal, Ozzie, Bob B, noemie maxwell, WisePiper, Ginny in CO, FightTheFuture, neroden, sodalis, coolbreeze, dsteffen, benny05, Rogneid, peacestpete, JanL, jbfunk, mightymouse, Snud, kathny, xaxnar, CJnyc, accumbens, Jim P, reddbierd, Mother Mags, martini, third Party please, LeftOverAmerica, kittania, mattinla, Shirl In Idaho, Nance, atdnext, BachFan, MissInformation, tarheelblue, Debbie in ME, Keone Michaels, DrSpalding, ej25, tobendaro, dharmafarmer, Themistoclea, profundo, Gorette, rl en france, Yellow Canary, cookseytalbott, seefleur, mooshter, Dvalkure, Below the Beltway, deha, fromer, arlene, raincrow, jwhitmill, kck, Lefty Coaster, blueoasis, megisi, NBBooks, DarkestHour, triv33, MJ via Chicago, global citizen, 4Freedom, Francine Shacter, gpoutney, cRedd, Glorfindel, gatorcog, Libby Shaw, imabluemerkin, tapestry, Sagebrush Bob, NearlyNormal, CF Perez, Frank Cocozzelli, Preston S, el cid, MarciaJ720, ZombyWoof, boatsie, ER Doc, Dinclusin, doinaheckuvanutjob, Pilgrim X, Pete Rock, JugOPunch, Sardanicas, lastamendment, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, RantNRaven, Dreaming of Better Days, goinsouth, blueoregon, MadMs, revgerry, shaharazade, airmarc, Statusquomustgo, PoxOnYou, bstotts, Temmoku, AllanTBG, NonnyO, ladypockt, seabos84, tegrat, ammasdarling, Evil Betty, bigchin, sephius1, One Pissed Off Liberal, Noor B, pgm 01, FoundingFatherDAR, timewarp, out of left field, lightfoot, bluicebank, DorothyT, Haningchadus14, Cat Whisperer, Loudoun County Dem, byDesign, dmh44, tgypsy, FWIW, Debs2, offgrid, gloriana, Positronicus, puakev, yoduuuh do or do not, jds1978, Outrider, Van Buren, Sydserious, LillithMc, Mary Mike, yowsta, tbirchard, ebiker, HeartlandLiberal, Jimdotz, terabytes, ezdidit, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, DWG, dww44, Anglo, Unbozo, glbTVET, Strabo, Orange County Liberal, HCKAD, jayden, Midwesterners, jedennis, akdude6016, mauro7inf, Back In Blue, SeaTurtle, jnhobbs, millwood, Moderation, Bridge Master, carpunder, uciguy30, Chico David RN, leonard145b, number six, JML9999, Zydekos, keikekaze, eyesoars, Hens Teeth, Terra Mystica, JDWolverton, MKinTN, revm3up, mconvente, railsplitter, TheFatLadySings, cruz, wayoutinthestix, MikePhoenix, scooter in brooklyn, zerone, Cordwainer, kjallen, Unique Material, elwior, treesrock, lineatus, KJG52, VL Baker, Captain Janeway, Happy Days, Calamity Jean, Lujane, rssrai, geomoo, icebergslim, pickandshovel, bluesheep, Jeff Y, rubine, Tam in CA, Thought Crime, mofembot, Seamus D, banger, change the Be, Horsefeathers, PMA, tampamatt, luckylizard, DixieDishrag, BYw, eddienutzak, ptolemynm, punkdavid, priceman, Quilldriver, magicsister, Mayfly, Danise94, immigradvocate, watercarrier4diogenes, papicek, jlms qkw, squarewheel, ZhenRen, legendmn, LaFeminista, bthespoon, Old Woman, clent, Hound Dog, 1BQ, Turn Left, Rhysling, nippersdad, soarbird, Ripeness Is All, Searching for Pericles, wtxdem, MTmarilyn, ARS, emboyo, greengemini, lostinamerica, output, An Affirming Flame, Carol in San Antonio, CanyonWren, Partisan Progressive, Patch Adam, CamillesDad1, IndyRobin, JesseCW, DefendOurConstitution, John Shade, Bindle, beijingbetty, zaka1, manucpa, ZilV, Lopez99, papahaha, sanglug, allep10, kevinpdx, synductive99, Joeytj, dalfireplug, Losty, stevenwag, sfarkash, maxzj05, DoggiesWatches, jan0080, Enzo Valenzetti, Tommymac, deviant24x, Leftcandid, Larsstephens, cassandraX, cezariusz, ZAP210, BigVegan, smileycreek, rb137, pyegar, FogCityJohn, publicv, drainflake77, Tea and Strumpets, amk for obama, David Harris Gershon, Interceptor7, biggiefries, wren400, wvmom, Ronald Singleterry, CrissieP, puffmeister, ctlrick, elginblt, ItsSimpleSimon, SoCalHobbit, theal8r, Earth Ling, robin0727, Funkygal, sluggahjells, Betty Pinson, martini drinking atheist, elengul, MsGrin, Floande, soaglow, Irony Raygun, Onomastic, praying manatheist, spindr27, Colorado is the Shiznit, angstall, spiraldancer8, Oldowan, Valerie8435, StateofEuphoria, nicethugbert, AuroraDawn, sophiedaisey, m00finsan, BlackQueen40, QuestionAuthority, Situational Lefty, Hatrax, princesspat, boomerchick, Haf2Read, marleycat, Lorikeet, RadicalRoadRat, dle2GA, muddy boots, felldestroyed, merrily1000, LSmith, PeggyD, createpeace, doctoraaron, Vtdblue, Tyto Alba, curtisgrahamduff, Archie2227, mfprtoo, daveusf, happenstance, OtterQueen, Anthony Page aka SecondComing, That Korean Guy, Sunspots, stlsophos, disillusionedbabyboomer, Ezekial 23 20, Willa Rogers, thejoshuablog, DRo, Nightshade Q, Regina in a Sears Kit House, Proleft, Kurt from CMH, jaebone, Cyndiannp, PrometheusUnbound, DawnN, Monsieur Georges, Free Chicken and Beer, Only Needs a Beat, mod2lib, angry marmot, oblios arrow, Williston Barrett, greenbastard, orestes1963, delmardougster, Eric Nelson, britexhumed, imchangeingagain, Brainy Smurf, Skritchard, 2thanks, Ginger1, congenitalefty, Celtic Pugilist, chicagobleu, ShirleyG

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site