Skip to main content

This is a depressing time to try to believe in the rule of law in this country, because of so much in the way of rampant fraud on behalf of the banking industry, the robo-signing, the delays and obfuscations, the obvious collusion, etc.  However, there is still a long history of the rule of law in this country, and even despite our philosophical and political differences, there are lots of good actors involved, at every level.   I have no idea of what political persuasion Judge Dennis Blackmon is, but Tea Partiers and Occupiers alike should be able to applaud his opinion in Otis Wayne Phillips v. US Bank.

Sometimes, only the courts of law stand to protect the taxpayer. Somewhere, someone has to stand up. Well, sometimes is now, and the place is the Great State of Georgia. The Defendant’s Motion is hereby Denied.

The court finds the following to be the facts and law applicable to this motion:  


-Otis Phillips is behind on his house payments and is in grave danger of foreclosure.  

-The United States Government paid taxpayer dollars to the largest of our financial institutions, and to European Union Banks, in order to prop up those poorly run organizations.

-Twenty Billion of those dollars were handed over to the defendant, U.S. Bank.  

-U.S. Bank agreed to participate in the U.S. Government's HAMP program to help struggling homeowners.

-U.S. Bank signed a Service Participation Agreement (SPA), in which the bailed out bank agreed to comply with the HAMP Guidelines for loan modification  

-The HAMP guidelines require U.S. Bank to perform modification services for all morgage loans it services.  

-Otis Phillips applied to modify his mortgage with U.S. Bank.  

-U..S. Bank denied the request, without numbers, figures, or explanation, reasoning, comparison to the guidelines, or anything.  U.S. Bank would not reveal to Mr. Phillips how his income, or his house, or his expenses would make him ineligible according to HAMP guidelines.  

(This court cannot imagine why U.S. Bank will not make known to Mr. Phillips, a taxpayer, how his numbers put him outside the federal guidelines to receive a loan modification.  Taking $20 Billion of taxpayer money was no problem for U.S. Bank. A cynical Judge might believe that this entire motion to dismiss is a desperate attempt to avoid the discovery period, where U.S. Bank would have to tell Mr. Phillips how his financial situation did not qualify him for a modification. Or, perhaps he was qualified, yet didn’t receive the modification, in violation of U.S. Bank’s Service Participation Agreement (SPA).  A cynical judge might think that, if the guidelines clearly prevented Mr Phillips from getting his modification, then US Bank would have trotted out that fact in mathematic equations, pie charts, and bar graphs, all on 8 by 10 glossy photo paper, with circles and arrows and paragraphs on the back explaining each winning number.1  U.S. Bank’s silence on this issue might heighten the suspicions of such a cynical jurist.  I, on the other hand, am sure that nothing of the sort could be true. Maybe US Bank no longer has any of the $20 billion dollars left, and so their lack of written explanation might be attributed to some kind of ink reduction program to save money. I’m sure there is a perfectly reasonable explanation for why US  Bank will not print out the ONE page of figures that show that Mr. Phillip’s financials compared to the HAMP guidelines to clear this all up.)

1.  Apologies to Arlo Guthrie, Alice's Restaurant.  

-Otis Phillips claims to have suffered as a result of U.S. Bank's actions, and

-Otis Phillips wishes to avoid foreclosure.  


Clearly, U.S. Bank cannot take the money, contract with our government to provide a a service to the taxpayer, violate that agreement, and then say no one on earth can sue them for it. That is not the law in Georgia. In fact, since no administrative review is provided in HAMP [which is something you should put in your OCC letter demanding review], the courts are the only recourse.  The Bank claims that the intended beneficiaries of HAMP are the very people who CAN'T sue.  Such argument is absurd.


Georgia prohibits wrongful foreclosures.  In fact, Federal law also prohibits wrongful foreclosures.  Mr. Phillips claims that U.S. Bank is not the proper party to pursue such an action, and is merely the servicer of the loan, not the holder.  Further, Mr. Phillips asserts that compliance with HAMP guidelines is a condition precedent to foreclosure.  


There is no merit to Defendant's motion to dismiss, and same is hereby denied.

That's the kind of thing that makes you believe in this country.  Congratulations, Judge Blackmon!  Picture of Judge Blackmon here.  

12:15 PM PT: Just want to say thanks to all who've stopped to read and rec.  Hope you enjoyed Judge Blackmon's wit as much as I did.  This is exactly the kind of thing that the Banks are trying to get immunity from, in the negotiations with Attorneys General all across the country, and from the U.S. Treasury and Justice Departments.  Judge Blackmon's opinion demonstrates just how stupid it would be for the A.G.'s, Tres., and Justice to do so; it's just common sense that these banks need to be held accountable, and the law provides a means to do so, if only they will let it.  

2:39 PM PT: Once again, thanks to all.  Time to go, so won't be responding to any more comments.  

Originally posted to Jbearlaw on Tue Nov 15, 2011 at 11:00 AM PST.

Also republished by ClassWarfare Newsletter: WallStreet VS Working Class Global Occupy movement.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Thumb, JekyllnHyde, Alumbrados, Angie in WA State, Doug in SF, JWC, buffalo soldier, Joe Bob, Mimikatz, jazzmaniac, Chi, Ray Radlein, itsbenj, True North, MadRuth, hester, Brainwrap, texaslucy, murphy, grollen, ogre, teacherken, AaronInSanDiego, glitterscale, dfarrah, Joan McCarter, Superribbie, badger, lost, Sprinkles, superfly, Emerson, Shockwave, jazzizbest, Pondite, Charles CurtisStanley, Stein, mslat27, celdd, Mnemosyne, xynz, polecat, kdub, x, elfling, frisco, grover, Just Saying, jancw, zeitshabba, Creosote, mengelhart, thepook, cinnamon68, Gustogirl, opinionated, j4k, Babsnc, afox, fugwb, Silverleaf, BlackSheep1, Wee Mama, wonkydonkey, mustang dvs, fishwars, mkfarkus, mrblifil, JJG Miami Shores, Aquarius40, chimpy, JuliaAnn, greenomanic, eataTREE, jbeach, jennifree2bme, ornerydad, jalbert, wonmug, Cedwyn, antirove, hopeful, Chrisfs, Yil, dksbook, bogbud, revsue, SneakySnu, EntrWriter, kharma, psnyder, danthrax, sockpuppet, Dallasdoc, Kamakhya, businessdem, Eddie in ME, Tracker, virginislandsguy, ranger995, chriscol, cosette, Ophelia, HeyMikey, dwahzon, ohiolibrarian, Steven Payne, Sychotic1, TX Scotia, Catte Nappe, Court Jester, Pohjola, inclusiveheart, outragedinSF, Oaktown Girl, blonde moment, AllisonInSeattle, zerelda, ybruti, davybaby, lonespark, zadarum, ScienceMom, Steven D, jcrit, American in Kathmandu, solesse413, eztempo, Josiah Bartlett, rmx2630, bibble, Maggie Pax, murrayewv, Armand451, sawgrass727, Gowrie Gal, Brecht, sachristan, nailbender, vcmvo2, la motocycliste, ExStr8, maybeeso in michigan, Bluesee, Simian, radarlady, Tinfoil Hat, boji, Ckntfld, Unit Zero, wmc418, UncleCharlie, m16eib, unclejohn, Chinton, democracy inaction, irate, PBen, vgranucci, Alice Venturi, one of 8, kitchen sink think tank, basquebob, juliesie, kiri, TigerMom, david78209, YucatanMan, Kevskos, 1180, cris0000, dansk47, majcmb1, SaraBeth, Dr Squid, Sun Tzu, HugoDog, nailmaker, where4art, GreyHawk, ladybug53, Ice Blue, most peculiar mama, markdd, babatunde, Rex Freedom, Yamara, kaliope, Tool, rb608, HiBob, Blu Gal in DE, Aint Supposed to Die a Natural Death, Floja Roja, FindingMyVoice, kerplunk, dazed in pa, dsteffen, Rogneid, Lindy, peacestpete, Arsenic, Snud, Jim R, Jim P, begone, debedb, forbodyandmind, lcork, alrdouglas, SoulCatcher, martini, Knucklehead, golfervet, kwmike, Nance, buddabelly, BachFan, tarheelblue, tommymet, Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse, sherlyle, cybersaur, 417els, Mr Bojangles, emeraldmaiden, Themistoclea, 8ackgr0und N015e, tonyahky, liberalconservative, seefleur, Dvalkure, ruleoflaw, sleipner, Loonesta, jenthor, arlene, sailmaker, jwhitmill, blueoasis, NBBooks, Remillard, The Hindsight Times, gooderservice, gatorcog, tapestry, JVolvo, joe shikspack, Sagebrush Bob, NearlyNormal, plf515, Preston S, myrealname, ER Doc, bsiii, middleagedhousewife, hlsmlane, Pilgrim X, llbear, onionjim, SingerInTheChoir, BlueMississippi, IL clb, rage, CA Nana, profh, Timothy J, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, Cassiodorus, kurt, zedaker, Statusquomustgo, kurious, bstotts, matx, Temmoku, blueintheface, kml, mapman, HM2Viking, Nulwee, Aaa T Tudeattack, Thinking Fella, tegrat, Tamar, bluicebank, anotherdemocrat, Russ Jarmusch, Loudoun County Dem, Mr K, oklacoma dem, jhecht, Debs2, devis1, ColoTim, NovatoBon, RAM, linkage, blue71340, FishOutofWater, Sydserious, la urracca, jeanette0605, Matt Z, flumptytail, DWG, suejazz, sfbob, coloradocomet, Shadowmage36, joedemocrat, bnasley, NoMoJoe, Seneca Doane, artisan, getlost, jayden, US Blues, stratocasterman, ubertar, BlueInKansas, letsgetreal, Killer of Sacred Cows, SeaTurtle, millwood, Moderation, OIL GUY, gaardvark, Chico David RN, Sarea, Korkenzieher, janatallow, spearfish, trueblueliberal, the1sage, South Park Democrat, TomP, Empower Ink, VA Breeze, MKinTN, adrianrf, gundyj, Clio2, also mom of 5, TheFatLadySings, HappyinNM, ScottyUrb, zerone, Johnny Nucleo, Youffraita, Senor Unoball, Involuntary Exile, dadadata, Laughing Vergil, Akonitum, jakebob, mikeconwell, Greyhound, Lujane, tofumagoo, Ocelopotamus, hankloy, Jake Williams, triplepoint, TokenLiberal, catly, home solar, envwq, Seamus D, ClapClapSnap, petulans, makettle, Cobbler, James Kresnik, My Spin, DixieDishrag, adobedragon, sagansong, magicsister, Mayfly, WearyIdealist, cactusflinthead, enufisenuf, scrambler, GrannyOPhilly, lissablack, lostboyjim, legendmn, Fiddlegirl, 207wickedgood, maggiejean, prettygirlxoxoxo, J M F, Independant Man, Leftcenterlibertarian, Glacial Erratic, Rick Aucoin, juca, iowaworker, Dopeman, LeftOfYou, Pale Jenova, Nebraskablue, FrugalGranny, BlueInRedCincy, dfe, shopkeeper, CamillesDad1, shalca, unspeakable, virginwoolf, MKSinSA, mksutherland, MySobriquet, Alise, Keith Pickering, synductive99, IDrankWhat, IreGyre, DreamyAJ, Question Authority, Northern Light, stevenwag, Lacy LaPlante, jimmylutherking, jfromga, Livvy5, deviant24x, Skex, Railfan, Amber6541, brentbent, coppercelt, mamamorgaine, confitesprit, p gorden lippy, RethinkEverything, NJpeach, Susan Grigsby, Observerinvancouver, David Harris Gershon, SmartAleq, eb23, luvsathoroughbred, Dan E in Blue Hampshire, alguien, freeport beach PA, dagnome, Focusmarker, 888, tb mare, DiegoUK, WattleBreakfast, jim283, Publius2008, ericlewis0, dalkman, Nada Lemming, petesmom, science nerd, Glass Navel, slice, Mac in Maine, Onomastic, Jane Lew, praying manatheist, redlum jak, TAH from SLC, mrbeen38, kerflooey, kamrom, ozsea1, sostos, nicethugbert, jardin32, myadestes, swale44, xylonjay, poorbuster, Susipsych, HiKa, aisb23, BirdMom, kevin k, it really is that important, lawyernerd, Alice Olson, feeny, boomerchick, mrsgoo, marleycat, Lorikeet, susanala, Cinnamon, badscience, shmevsmom, fklehman, muddy boots, Yogurt721, floridablue, merrily1000, Idgie Threadgoode, LSmith, nogo postal, Fire bad tree pretty, fossil fish, antooo, antimony, Keori, sound of progress, poliwrangler, Wood Dragon, Caddis Fly, beforedawn, Vatexia, joey c, Ubiquitous A, SoCalSal, SteelerGrrl, just another vortex, weinerschnauzer, jham710, DRo, googie, aerie star, Mentatmark, SouthernLiberalinMD, T100R, MichaelNY, allergywoman, I C Mainer, No one gets out alive, ThothXXI, livingthedream, Patric Juillet, weatherdude, daysey, Orman West, stormicats, Liberal Granny, OldDragon, Heart n Mind, anodnhajo, sow hat, Catskill Julie, Williston Barrett, Mindful Nature, Chrislove, We Won, Citizenpower, IndieGuy, Jakkalbessie, EclecticCrafter, wordfiddler, ahumbleopinion, a2nite, 420 forever, FloridaSNMOM, exatc, Horace Boothroyd III, This old man, InAntalya, Mr Robert, Mark Tietig, Mike RinRI, peachcreek, TBug, Arahahex, qannabbos, Margd, wxorknot, AverageJoe42, ItsaMathJoke, Stance Like Ptah, George3, Marjmar, katiec, databob, Windowpane, BradyB, madcitysailor, Sue B, GoGoGoEverton, Lensy, John Crapper, ebailey, onceasgt, JFeathersmith, The grouch, Late Again, glorificus, Pickwick, Praxical, KalHermit, Setsuna Mudo, Another Grizzle

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site