Skip to main content

There is an incredible force of New Mexico government officials, horse industry representatives, and special interests in New Mexico pushing for a horse slaughter house on US soil. Currently there is a bill at the NM State Legislature, HB90, that lacks about 10 votes to pass the House and could come back at any time, according to Representative Jimmie Hall. In order to garner support HB90 is apparently awaiting a story on “starving unwanted horses” on tribal lands.


These pro-horse slaughter forces have used the First Americans in a dishonorable and even slanderous way for years in pro-slaughter propaganda. This slander was evidenced from the statement that “Native Americans eat horses”, by then Executive Director of the NMLB in committee at the NM legislature in 2007, as well as the current drum beat of statements by the contingent mentioned above, of “thousands of feral horses on tribal lands, ruining the environment”.

No tribal official is ever named and no actual counts or environmental assessments are ever given as proven by a recent Inspection of public records request (IPRA) to the New Mexico Department of Agriculture, whose Director, Jeff Witte , is running a Task Force on Horse Overpopulation.


This Task Force (TF) on horse overpopulation was initiated by the New Mexico Cattle Growers' Association (NMCGA) and the New Mexico Farm & Livestock Bureau (NMFLB) in a letter  to Governor Martinez on April 19th, 2012. However, Jeff Witte, Director of the NM Department of Agriculture stated at the 1/18/13 TF meeting that he and Bill Sauble, a New Mexico Livestock Board member, came up with the idea.


The EUROPEAN COMMISSION (HEALTH AND CONSUMERS DIRECTORATE-GENERAL) (2011-8906) in 2011, shows that 19,203 horses were rejected from slaughter for human consumption at the Mexican border. This due to disease, pregnancy, being ungelded, and/or improper paperwork.

Nineteen Thousand Two Hundred Three Horses
Rejected at the Mexican Border in 11 months in 2011

1,522 breaches against the zoosanitairy requirements and 232 cases of the presence of live ticks were identified
This is a massive number compared to the meager 71 estrays (lost or abandoned) New Mexico horses. What does a kill buyer do with a trailer load of horses rejected for slaughter? DUMP!

In the Task Force initiation letter NMCGA and NMFLB state:
“horses are destined for slaughter plants in Mexico. . .”  “Mexico will not accept intact studs (males) or pregnant mares. . .” “Numerous unwanted horses are merely hauled to an open space --- including private, federal, tribal or state lands. There they are either turned loose to fend for themselves or perhaps shot on-sight. These horses create grave concern for livestock owners and managers due to the potential for disease transmission. . .” “Because of New Mexico's border with Mexico, the state is recipient of unwanted horses from the entire nation. “

Though counter intuitive, a horse slaughter plant is exactly what causes this dumping: not the economy,  high hay prices, not even over breeding. Many of these horses were not diseased at the beginning of their trip.


In the KRQE story on the Task Force, Jeff Witte NM State Secretary of Agriculture states: “There are no hard numbers as to how many horses are wild, abandoned or feral in New Mexico, but some estimates are as high as 90,000 on the Navajo reservation alone.” "We've had estimates of tens of thousand of horses that have been released across the state either on Forest Service, BLM land or tribal land,"

Jeff Witte makes no mention of who is releasing these TENS OF THOUSANDS of horses in New Mexico.  Instead of educating the public that kill buyers are dumping them, he withholds this vital information leaving it up in the air for people to assume that New Mexicans are abandoning "unwanted" horses, while he implies the biggest problem is the "Indians". Masterfully, this administration plays on peoples prejudices they didn't even have.

You might ask, are New Mexico government officials planning a raid on the Navajo’s to “rescue” their horses? No, they are beating the drum for a slaughter plant in New Mexico.

Interestingly, in this same KRQE story the Placitas Wild Horses are pictorially featured or rather “fingered”.


photo by Kevin Larson  Free Mountain

New Mexico’s Senator Sapien is working to ensure that the San Felipe Pueblo does not regain their ancestral aboriginal lands by Placitas. If Senator Sapien succeeds, against the will of most Placitans, and the San Felipe Pueblo, the Placitas Wild Horses will be sent to federal holding pens rather than managed as wild horses, or worse, they will be deemed livestock and most sent to slaughter.

Incredulously, the week before HB90 was to be voted on in the NM House Appropriations and Finance Committee (HAFC), a “cattle pot” load of skinny and wormy Dumped horses landed on the border of San Felipe and Diamond Tail Ranch over 6 miles from the San Felipe Pueblo proper.  Interestingly, this seems to have been a manufactured two for one story, to get HB90 passed, and to tarnish irreparably, San Felipe Pueblo, to try and end the massive Placitan support for the San Felipe Pueblo and the hopes for the Placitan horses as legal wild life. Investigations of these illegal activities are in progress.

In case the reader is worried, or has heard the slanderous rumors, these dumped horses were in fact not trapped, as fences were down in many places; contrary to reports by a representative of the Sandoval Signpost and a member of the pro-slaughter New Mexico Horse Council on Facebook, there were no dead horses, and these were not the wild horses that roam San Felipe. However San Felipe is assisting these horses with hay and water and they are recovering.

These were to be the Judas horses leading many others to slaughter in New Mexico, but now they too have escaped slaughter, and the San Felipe Pueblo has stated that: “Slaughter is not an option”.



  1. New Mexicans have a right to know the truth. New Mexico’s estray (abandoned and lost) horses average a mere 71 horses per year according to the New Mexico Livestock Board data base since 2005 by WHOA IPRA.
  2. Slaughter plant proximity is the cause of massive numbers of “unwanted” horses. We must end the transport of American horses to Mexico for slaughter in order to stop the horse dumping in New Mexico. Even when the US had horse slaughter plants, thousands of US horses went to slaughter in Mexico. For example in 2004 17,636 horses went to slaughter in Mexico per USDA FAS.   Please Support US American Prevention of Slaughter Act.
  3. Additionally, New Mexico statutes allow for technicians, rather than veterinarians, to euthanize unwanted horses.  NMSA CHAPTER 77 Animals and Livestock > ARTICLE 1B Animal Sheltering > 77-1B-6. Euthanasia technician; license.
  4. There are over 9 Million horses in the US. Of these, 900,000 horses/yr die and are disposed of humanely. These methods include; euthanasia, death, composting, rendering, and affordable group cremation.
  5. Horse Slaughter is not Humane Euthanasia in the US, in Canada, or in Mexico. Also, the recent Lake Research Poll shows that 80% of Americans oppose slaughter.
  6. Horses are not raised as food animals and they contain drugs not intended for use in food animals. These are dangerous and that is why the FDA does not allow the sale of American horse meat in the US.


  1. Livestock have no rights and are exempt from the Animal Cruelty Laws of New Mexico. They are subject to auction and slaughter.
  2. Under WHOA’s plan the Placitas Horses will be recognized as legally wild animals with commensurate rights. This can be realized under the BLM’s or San Felipe Pueblo’s jurisdiction, through the current RMP  public process, or through the court proceedings now in progress. The Placitas Horses would be administered birth control to manage their population in both cases.  Excess numbers would not be subject to slaughter.
  3. Under Senator Sapien’s plan, the BLM would be transferred to the state of the New Mexico under the RPP&P  Act, the horses would be considered livestock and be subject to culling, auction, and slaughter. Additionally, the Governor has given no promise to allow any of the horses to remain. This plan would also disenfranchise Placitans from the public NEPA process which is nearing completion after 5 yrs.
  4. The State of New Mexico has been working to block the use of birth control on the Placitas wild horses, using the pretext of their lack of an owner as a way to keep them from receiving birth control. In fact, the people of the United States and the people of New Mexico, own them. If the state was interested in these horses, or the safety of Placitans, they would authorize rather than block WHOA from administering birth control.


  1. HB90: Call Governor Martinez: (505) 476-2200  email: (
    Tell her Slaughter is what is causing the unwanted horses in NM and a slaughter plant here will only make it worse.
    Call Governor Martinez: (505) 476-2200  email: (
    Call Senator Sapien:     (505) 765-5662  email: (
    Ask them both not to disenfranchise Placitans by taking the Placitas BLM and/or deeming the Placitas horses as livestock.
  3. STOP HORSE SLAUGHTER IN MEXICO AND CANADA: Call federal representatives and request they co-sponsor and support The American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act.

For most stats in this Diary, see Unintended Consequences of Slaughter for U.S. here.

Originally posted to meepdog on Tue Feb 26, 2013 at 02:28 AM PST.

Also republished by DK GreenRoots.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  This is an important story (6+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    kurt, meepdog, Ojibwa, KayCeSF, SilentBrook, Rogneid

    that probably will get lost in the sequester (not that it isn't important that we solve it) mania. "Excess" horses exist because we humans breed too many of them, mainly for horse racing. When they don't develop into multiple Grade I stakes winners, or break down and can't race any more, and if they can't be used as show horses or sold as pets, they are often sold off for slaughter. This is entirely a problem of humanity's own making, and these beautiful animals don't deserve to suffer for our greed.

    You might want to re-post this early next week, before the next full-blown crisis hits.


    •  not necessarily race horses though there are (5+ / 0-)

      excess foals there due to the practice of breeding stock mares to foal at the same time as thoroughbreds so the stock mare can be a nurse mare for the thoroughbred foal when it is thrown.  Her own foal is usually slaughtered.

      Another reason is urine farms.  For those not familiar:

      For those interested in how equines are used other than as riding animals here is a list of equine rescue organization sites

      (disclaimer: years ago I was involved in equine rescue and continue to support their goals)

      •  Rachel Alexandra's foal is being raised (2+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        radarlady, meepdog

        with a nurse mare (a quarter horse). The nurse mare's foal is being hand raised and will become a reining/cattle horse. Not all nurse mare foals are slaughtered.

        I reject your reality and substitute my own - Adam Savage

        by woolibaar on Tue Feb 26, 2013 at 05:41:55 AM PST

        [ Parent ]

        •  True, but Rachel's a high-profile case (1+ / 0-)
          Recommended by:

          The way she's followed on the Tubes, I'm not surprised there weren't live-streams of her deliveries. So if something were to happen to the nurse mare foal, there would be a storm of protest. There are a lot of nurse mare foals who aren't so lucky.

          Radarlady, a BIG Rachel fan (I have the Breyer Rachel, which I probably shouldn't admit too forcefully), who wishes her a very speedy recovery for her intestinal problems

  •  since the issue of horsemeat has been discussed (4+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    ybruti, meepdog, SilentBrook, Rogneid

    on KOS before, with some here defending it as being a cultural norm in some places, I have to ask again if there is a reason that horse meat should be on the table?

    I note a growing scandal in the EU where horse meat is on the menu:

    and also note that there is no shortage of beef in this country, to my knowledge to make such a switch imperative.  Traditionally the switch has always been to pork or chicken

    As far as protestations that horses are menu items in other cultures, I can only observe that canines have been food sources in the past and still are in some cultures

    After all, there is as much reason for Rover and Fido to show up in a casserole as Silver or Trigger.  

  •  Horses are being abandoned and starved (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    all over the country, not because a slaughter house exists, but because slaughter houses that used to exist were closed down.
    Up here in CT, we have more horses per capita and more horses per acre than any other state. Horses get old and unsound, they get injured, they can become dangerous if they've been mishandled.
    When there were killer auctions, the owner of such a horse could dispose of it and get a few cents per pound. Now they have to find some other way to deal. Burying a horse in not easy or cheap. And it's not clean. One horse owner in Monroe buried five horses on his 3 acre "farm", polluting the wells of several of his neighbors. Those horses should have gone to auction.
    We have a bunch of "rescue" operations here where 30 or 40 horses stand around in pens waiting to die. They are fed and watered, at staggering cost to the rescuers, until they run out of money then the horses starve.
    A lot of these rescue horses end up being abused and many of them are dangerous to their owners.
    Those abandoned horses on BLM land, the so called "wild horses" (there are NO indigenous wild horses in this hemisphere, they were abandoned Spanish horses that spread across the west) get rounded up and sent east where they have demolished the market for purebred horses. You can get a horse from out west for less than the cost of shipping, why would you buy a well bred horse that cost the breeder a couple thousand dollars just to get it on the ground?
    Well, for one thing, you have no idea what that horse IS, whether it is trainable or a war pony, whether it has been damaged or is diseased, it is a pig in a poke. And unlike a reputable breeder, the BLM doesn't back their buyers up.
    Shutting down the slaughterhouses was an extremely bad mistake and finally, the USFDA has reversed themselves after seeing the disastrous results. Too late for a lot of good horse breeders and even for some of the breeds. The Morgan Horse, the first American breed, is almost gone, partly because the breeders can't compete with the flood of BLM horses.
    I understand that this is an emotional issue, that lots of people have an attachment to horses, but horse slaughter is, by comparison to what we've seen since it was stopped, humane.

    If I ran this circus, things would be DIFFERENT!

    by CwV on Tue Feb 26, 2013 at 07:42:18 AM PST

    •  Did you read the EU report quotes in the article? (1+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:

      Curious. It states almost 20,000 horses rejected at the Mexican Border in less than one year, and the cattle folks state:

      These horses create grave concern for livestock owners and managers due to the potential for disease transmission. . .” “Because of New Mexico's border with Mexico, the state is recipient of unwanted horses from the entire nation. “

      These are not my words or my doing. How is this explained away?

      •  Blowback (0+ / 0-)

        Because there were no US slaughterhouses, they were being transported to Mexico and Canada. If the international border vet rejects them for transport, the shipper then is stuck with a truckload of horses that no one wants. So the answer they come up with is to dump them anywhere that they can, that no one will find them until the shipper is in a different state.
        And yes. that can mean any number of problems from disease to vermin to grazing and water competition (which is the real concern for the cattlemen, since most equine diseases don't effect cattle or other livestock).
        And it can lead to a really ugly death for these animals from dehydration, starvation and hyperthermia in the desert.
        All, unintended consequences of the ban on domestic equine slaughter.
        BTW not all of these horses go for food. They are used for hides, hair, gelatin and any number of other things, so even diseased horses are used.

        If I ran this circus, things would be DIFFERENT!

        by CwV on Tue Feb 26, 2013 at 11:24:02 AM PST

        [ Parent ]

  •  Tacos (0+ / 0-)

    Drought due to Climate Change & over population of humans competing for water has stressed the wild horse herds. Hay is expensive due to drought.

    •  Climate Change true, a cause to a lesser degree. (0+ / 0-)

       Almost 20,000 horses rejected at the Mexican Border in less than one year, and the cattle folks state:

      These horses create grave concern for livestock owners and managers due to the potential for disease transmission. . .” “Because of New Mexico's border with Mexico, the state is recipient of unwanted horses from the entire nation. “

      These are not my words or my doing. How is this explained away?

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site