Quote from John Batchelor
"Additional: Ping Fu's careful recounting of her recollections of life during Mao's Cultural Revolution has brought down on her head the wrath of current Chinese Communist Party hacks, who pay digital hirelings the rough equivalent of fifty cents a post to write pedestrian criticisms and flood American readers and publishers with clearly nonfactual complaints. The acrimony of the PRC bureaucrats suggests that Ping Fu has hit a nail on the head. "American citizen taking foreign government money to hack American system and attack American citizen, especially advisor of current President?
That constitutes treason!
John Batchelor, Do you know what you are saying? Do you mean what you are saying?
It is just criticisms, negative reviews, just critics equipped with facts. Why do you need to frame them and tie them to a foreign government?
That is exactly what happened during Cultural Revolution!
During the Cultural Revolution, if you dared to criticize the government, you would be labeled anti-revolutionary, if you ever had any tie to foreign country, you would be marked as a spy.
How ironic! This is exactly Cultural Revolution style persecution!
What no longer happens in China today is actually happening here in the US!
John Batchelor, you are not only talking about Cultural Revolution, you are practicing Cultural Revolution in the US!
pedestrian criticisms ... clearly nonfactual complaints1. Multiple individual FOIA requests had confirmed, with official response from PD of Albuquerque, New Mexico, that there was no record of any incident relates to Ping Fu during that responsible period of time. Either you accept that Ping Fu's kidnapping claim is false, or you are accusing the police of incompetence or negligence of duty.
2. In her Memoir Bend, Not Break, in the very first paragraph, Ping Fu claimed to have to choose either be expelled to US or be sent to remote area in China.
Please tell us:
a. Why would the government, any government for that matter, send its citizen to other country as punishment?
b. Why would the alleged criminal be given two opposite choices, one being punished in remote areas, one being set free and live in a more advanced free world?
It defies reality and logic, you actually believed it? Would any school in the US discipline a student by sending the student to Disneyland?
This is Ping Fu's words against her own words, in print, can you deny it?
...current Chinese Communist Party hacks, who pay digital hirelings...equivalent of fifty cents...This is your claim, is it fact?
1. How do you know it is from Chinese government? You even knew the amount of money paid? Where is your basic journalist principle? Are you told to say this or are you paid to say this? Show us the evidence!
2. If Chinese government were behind this.
a. Why wouldn't Chinese government directly (or assist the hirelings to) expose Ping Fu's school record to denounce her academic claim?
b. Why wouldn't Chinese government directly (or assist the hirelings to ) clarify that Ping Fu was never deported or expelled?
c. Why would Chinese government choose the most inefficient way to pay hirelings to post in limited forums for months (instead of using its powerful propaganda machine)?
d. Why would Chinese government allow Ping Fu to publish her memoir in China in 1996?
e. Why would Chinese government honor Ping Fu in its official propaganda machine China Daily?
Is that what a deportee could do? Is that what a government does to its deportee?
Truth will prevail, get your listeners well informed, let them make their own judgement.
John Batchelor, since you already have solid evidence (you even knew the pay rate) to prove there are foreign agents or American citizen working for foreign government, please point them out, assist the law enforcement to bring the perpetrators to justice!