Skip to main content

TopCommentsRedux

Happy Mother's Day!!!

Now, with that said, we're REALLY going to continue in a pre-Stonewall manner. Why? Your mother (that's me) is going to remind you how this inquiry into pre-Stonewall gay culture began by explaining James McCourt and his approach to the era in which he came of age. Especially since your mother had a diary all set up with all the Top Comments apparatus in it in which she was going to continue her inquiry into Camp that just disappeared. I think that was a sign that said "Not tonight."

After a word from our sponsor.

Top Comments recognizes the previous day's Top Mojo and strives to promote each day's outstanding comments through nominations made by Kossacks like you. Please send comments (before 9:30pm ET) by email to topcomments@gmail.com or by our KosMail message board.

I had this linked, but it occurred to me that most of you hadn't read it (five of you, of course HAVE), and it's a week short of being two years old anyway. So here is most of the first diary I wrote for what was going to be a series on Literary LGBT History for the remembering LGBT History diary (which, as you'll remember, was created in a comment thread in a Top Comments diary), which is now the LGBT Literature series for the Readers and Book Lovers group. I give you the cult author James McCourt. I was reminded of this last night on the way back from a benefit for Aids Project Los Angeles that I had attended with the Kossack recoveringConservative who is, like me, an opera buff and who, when I brought it up in conversation, had never heard of the first book discussed in this diary. One more act of recovery.

About the author:
Photobucket
From The East Hampton Star, we learn that McCourt was born July 4 1941 in Flushing Hospital. He grew up in Jackson Heights near the #7 IRT line, and went to Catholic schools.  He graduated from Manhattan College in 1962. He then earned an M.A. at New York University and went on to study acting at Yale Drama School.

From his partner, the photo editor Vincent Virga:

After Lindenhurst High School, I went to St. Bonaventure University, and then to Yale Graduate School where in 1964 I met my life-partner, the writer James McCourt who had a deep and abiding friendship with the musical genius Victoria de los Angeles. (Her love and her art became a cornerstone of our lives together.) Jimmy and I went to live in London for nearly 5 years before returning home to NYC for the publication of his story Mawrdew Czgowchwz and for the making of a life in the city of my dreams.
From his literary agent:
James McCourt is the author of the MAWRDEW CZGOWCHWZ, as well as NOW YOYAGERS and QUEER STREET, a Publishers Weekly Best Book of 2003. He is also the author of three novels including TIME REMAINING, which Harold Bloom called one of the 100 best novels of the 20th century. He has published two short story collections and his work has appeared in the Yale Review, The New Yorker, and The Paris Review.
and from Dennis Cooper (of all people), who is a fan:
McCourt is that rarest of contemporary American authors -- a true iconoclast, a devoted high stylist, and a holder of the unfashionable opinion that prose is a natural extrovert and beauty that deserves the brightest polish, the best accessories, the most extravagant costumes. McCourt's work has been described as a marriage of Ronald Firbank's meticulous, delirious camp and Don DeLillo's maximalist historiography, which wouldn't be too wildly inaccurate if McCourt weren't a whole lot more mischevious and uninhibited than DeLillo.
The opus:
Fiction
    Mawrdew Czgowchwz (Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1975)
    Kaye Wayfaring in “Avenged” (stories) (Viking, 1985)
    Time Remaining (stories) (Knopf, 1993)
    Delancey's Way (Knopf, 2000)
    Wayfaring at Waverly in Silverlake (stories) (Knopf, 2002)
    Now Voyagers (Turtle Point Press, 2008)
Nonfiction
    Queer Street: Rise and Fall of an American Culture, 1947-1985 (W.W. Norton, 2003)
As for "chronicler of gay New York," yes, the dates put his work as a kind of sequel to George Chauncey's book.  McCourt's project, however, is vastly different.  We know there were gay people in the big port cities after World War II, so they didn't have to be discovered or uncovered. McCourt is chronicling a specific type of gay life, the gay culture that has supposedly disappeared because we've become more assimilated:  opera, cinema, "knowing" and sex wherever you found it (some people, like me, refer to this as the "Church of Cole Porter").  Something else that probably wouldn't come to mind for some of you. McCourt is eight years older than I am, but since he was 20 in 1961 and I was 20 in 1969, four months after Stonewall (which I'm just using as a point of reference), we might as well be from different generations.

So, the three essential books.

Mawrdew Czgowchwz

About Mawrdew Czgowchwz.  The publisher (Random House) says:

Diva Mawrdew Czgowchwz (pronounced "Mardu Gorgeous") bursts like the most brilliant of comets onto the international opera scene, only to confront the deadly malice and black magic of her rivals. Outrageous and uproarious, flamboyant and serious as only the most perfect frivolity can be, James McCourt's entrancing send-up of the world of opera has been a cult classic for more than a quarter-century. This comic tribute to the love of art is a triumph of art and love by a contemporary American master.
Well, yes.  On one level, it's a retelling of the Maria Callas-Renata Tebaldi "feud"
(the singers weren't feuding, their fans were, and in a precursor to the disco era, this was gay men vs. older Italian women), although there's a little of Victoria de los Angeles in Mawdrew as well. It's also a memorial to the Old Met, which was located at Broadway and 39th Street from 1883 to October 1964, when it moved to the brand-new Lincoln Center.
120011pr
(Historic American Buildings Survey, May 1966, VIEW FROM SOUTHEAST. - Metropolitan Opera House, 1423 Broadway, New York; Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division)

But then, HOO-boy, this is an absolute tour-de-force. Church of Cole Porter?  Unabashed opera queen is more like it.  Parts of it had me in tears on the rereading. This is an essential book. So what if the last 30 pages don't work very well?  Here's McCourt describing her Met debut as Violetta in La Traviata, as she negotiates the big aria at the end of the first act:

Bolting from the sofa, silencing the delirious applause at the end of the "Ah, forse e lui," she let out two "follie! that were "louder and wider than anything heard in Italian opera since Emmy Destinn" [Paranoy, next day in a broadside proclamation distributed everywhere] Shock waves hammered the listening throng.  The Principessa Oriana Incantevole heard and fell to her knees in the Neri box raving of miracle cures.  The three "gioire's" were each of them bigger than anyone's "hojotoho's." Disbelief, suspended, choked itself and dissolved.
You get the point. Her debut as Isolde is even more dramatic.

And, from Wayne Koestenbaum's introduction to the 2002 reissue:

Although McCourt does not hesitate to connect connoisseurship to what a sociologist might call a “gay fan-base,” his novel skimps eroticism, despite its romantic ending, and despite the prose’s nonstop orgasm. Rapture is reserved for the voice of its heroine and its plural narrators (Rodney, Jameson O’Maurigan, Mother Maire Dymphna, and others contribute to the polyphony). Energy’s displacement from eroticism to music has nothing to do with the “closet” or with prudishness, for music is not a code for sexuality: rather, music is a sexuality. (Listen to McCourt: “She sang four Mahler songs so profoundly that the spontaneous quality of the act itself was subsumed in a longing moment that seemed to have been absolutely destined to occur, to be accomplished only and for all time then and there in merely that way.”)
Besides, any book that has voodoo spells and characters named Lavinia O'Maurigan Stein and Merovig Creplaczx . . .  VERY worth reading, and not just to prepare you for the rest of his work.

Time Remaining

Time Remaining, which is composed of two stories (actually, a short story  - "I go back to the Mais Oui" -- and a novella -- "Time Remaining [A Chance to Talk]"), is McCourt's AIDS novel (it's a memorial to the poet James Schuyler), and here it gets even more complicated because he's discussing men who are are between 10 and 20 years older than he is, his "mothers," as the older generation would have it. The pronouns may get confusing in this section. The first time I read this, almost twenty years ago. I was absolutely overwhelmed by the power of the book, and I was absolutely sure I would assign at least the first story if I ever got the chance. If you want the material you might get from an oral history of gay New York between 1955 and Stonewall told by a very garrulous gay man, this will do it, but you really need to read Mawrdew Czgowchwz first.

"I go back to the Mais Oui" (and I'm not even sure which bar or performance space this refers to) introduces us to Delancey, a performance artist, remembering most of the characters from Mawrdew Czgowchwz and some of a group of drag queens who called themselves the "Eleven Against Heaven," and a soiree musicale at a big house in East Hampton in 1956 that is interrupted by the news that the painter Jackson Pollock had been killed in an automobile accident nearby. Also a trip to the eastern Mediterranean and a summer in Cherry Grove. Allusions, and allusions, and allusions, and maybe I'll write a book about my life beginning with the reform school I was sent to as a teenager. An entr'acte, if you will, to the main event.

"Time Remaining" is the main event, an interrupted monologue by Odette/Danny O'Doyle, another surviving member of the "Eleven Against Heaven," who has just returned form a grand tour of Europe, undertaken to dispose of the cremated ashes of eight of them in exactly the way each man wanted his ashes disposed of. This monologue is conducted (with Delancey in attendance) on a night run on the Long Island Railroad from Penn Station to Montauk. The novella gets its power from the sheer weight of all the memories Detta is recounting, especially since it tells you what was possible after the war for one of the gay war veterans Allan Bérubé discusses in Coming Out Under Fire: The History of Gay Men and Women in World War II.

Here, we get a sense that the old gay culture is becoming moribund because so many of our most interesting people have succumbed to AIDS, which is probably true.  Ayn Rand and the spies Donald MacLean and Guy Burgess appear in this section, as do complaints about gay Republicans and ACT UP (here called ACT/OUT):

What if I agreed not to put down ACT/OUT if they would agree to stop calling me and my kind retro masochistic self-loathing detritus of the bad old days? History is written by the winners, dear, and in this case by the survivors -- a history that contains all the abreactions, all the compensations for disallowing the complicated feelings of the actual losers, the dead?
Mostly gay New York, but also gay London and gay Paris and gay Milan and gay Venice and gay Vienna and Amsterdam and Copenhagen.  Read, read, read!

Queer Street

And then there's Queer Street, which might as well be labeled "cultural literacy for the young queen" because it is a compendium of what the socially ambitious young man in New York needed to know and be conversant with to be (accepted? welcomed?) by his older peers. Turns out George Chauncey reads the book that way too. McCourt has called this "the back story to Time Remaining.

The first time I looked at it, in bookstores, it appeared to be one bon mot after another. The second time, I thought it was simply McCourt doing a data dump of all his unpublished notebooks. This time, while I think the book definitely needed an editor, I found that there are parts of it that constitute required reading if you want to know what gay New York was like in the 1960s and into the 1970s. And the good part is that it's all true.

As Chauncey writes,

Gay men who knew the 1950's and 60's will find in this book a nostalgic compendium of names of long-forgotten bars, bathhouses and subway ''tearooms'' (public restrooms), novels and novelists, Warhol superstars and pornography superstuds. But those born after 1950 may find many of Mr. McCourt's references so allusive as to be elusive, since they often appear in lists without explication or description.
I'm on the time border here. I know (and have been to) some of the places he's talking about, but nowhere near all of them. I experienced some of the compendium in the 70's: Uncle Charlie's (uptown, downtown, the restaurant), Julius, the 55th Street Playhouse, the Adonis.  I can't (or is it "won't) tell you how much I learned at the Everard Baths, and yes, I have memories of the Continental, the Club and (especially) the St. Mark's.

Some of the topics that McCourt explains in depth:  Bette Davis, "All About Eve," Susan Sontag, Notes on Camp [Gay liberation, above all, really endangered high camp], "Vertigo,"  The Astor Bar, City of Night, stardom, Luchino Visconti, Douglas Sirk, Joe Ackerly, Ronald Firbank, the poets James Schuyler and James Merrill, Larry Kramer and Gay Men's Health Crisis, (the transgressive) Mae West, Joe Gage, and, of course, Thuh Opra (with a ten-page discussion of "diva" by an avid student of the subject). At the risk of being too didactic here, that list as it is significant to gay life is essential knowledge, so off to the google with you for the items you don't recognize. Mother's Church of Cole Porter Project (at least most of it)!

I could blockquote you into oblivion from this book, but I won't. However, when I say "true," I mean

Old Queer Fuck on the Park Bench:
"I hate to be a pill . . . but the facts are these: it was neither Larry Kramer's hysterics, the courageous reporting of the New York Native, Everett Koop's blinding-hot moral flash or anything less that turned the tide of AIDS recognition in America and of AIDS research funding by the American government.  It was nothing less or other than Ronald Reagan's sentimental -- goddamnit -- feelings for a fellow guy he just happened to like a whole hell of a lot from their Hollywood days, a guy called Rock Hudson who came down with the goddamn thing. And if you don't think them's the facts, go look them up.

Of course, there's also this:

Visiting Los  Angeles, time and time again . . . purpose: to get it all down -- the mystery, the mutability, the enveloping allure of this force field antipodal to New York, and always reforming the idea of it as the birthplace of that reactive and ultimately benighted twentieth-century homosexual hypothesis, Gay Liberation.
Well, okay. The fact is that there is a New York vs anywhere else dynamic, especially in gay life. In Queer Street you get the impression that Gay Liberation caused a rupture in the lives of McCourt and his circle.  From my vantage point, whatever.

Yes, it needs an editor.  So read it in pieces!  Beside, there's a reference to Walter Benjamin's essay, "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction!" Queer Street is erudite on a subject that isn't always covered with erudition, and it doesn't neglect the idea of sex altogether. And you don't have to wander through a forest of footnotes.

Three significant books by a writer you may not have heard of. Enjoy the discovery, and marvel at the representation of (at least) pre-Stonewall New York by a man who can turn a phrase.  

And now for the stuff that makes this Top Comments:

TOP COMMENTS, May 11, 2014: Thanks to tonight's Top Comments contributors! Let us hear from YOU when you find that proficient comment.

From LinSea:

For wisdom and encouragement, this comment by The Marti in Dragon5616's CUA diary.
From Tara the Antisocial Social Worker:
GreyHawk had a nice verbal/visual combo in the front-page diary by Dante Atkins,Republican fundraising off Benghazi proves craven political intent. Also flagged by lineatus.
Annieli offered this pithy description of the Tea Party in Egberto Willes's front-page diary Mission Accomplished:  The 'Tea Party' Won.
From your diarist, Dave in Northridge:
In Christian Dem in NC*s diary about the Benham Brothers and HGTV, *edg's reply to LillithMc' s complaint about censorship at National Review Online is just priceless. Also flagged by LillithMc.
TOP MOJO, May 10, 2014 (excluding Tip Jars and first comments):
  1) This is even dumber than the Bundy incident. by JamesGG — 189
  2) Is it very wrong of me to take so much pleasure... by Retroactive Genius — 148
  3) The right-wing movement is the disturbing part. by JamesGG — 117
  4) Hey GOP...you built that by JackND — 71
  5) Excellent news. by common green — 70
  6) They watered, fertilized and nurtured by Siri — 69
  7) How can it be wrong when... by lowkell — 66
  8) If you have a good lawyer, a bad appeal ruling can by zenbassoon — 64
  9) Yeah, it's baffling by Tara the Antisocial Social Worker — 64
10) What's the ant's position by Tara the Antisocial Social Worker — 62
11) Dr. Frankenstein meet the angry villagers n/t by konving — 61
12) If you were to include a link in your post, by weezilgirl — 61
13) Furious, indeed. Despite the vast amount of... by Meteor Blades — 59
14) Utterly despicable by Port City Moon — 54
15) There have been a number of protest by Richard Lyon — 53
16) Been that way for a while. by AnnieR — 53
17) People always talk about slippery slopes. This one by SphericalXS — 50
18) Happy Caturday before Mother's Day! by CoolOnion — 47
19) "Culture of life" by oruacat2 — 47
20) This is why the Bundy ranch Cosplay Cowboys by CwV — 47
21) The law is supposed to work at time of incident by Vetwife — 47
22) I hope you're right! by democracy inaction — 47
23) They could get off their asses and hike. by samanthab — 46
24) fineena has rescued these two babies and loves by edrie — 46
25) And this is why by The Dude 415 — 46
26) Like in the Manifesto of the Communist by gnothis — 45
27) They can no longer see anything by raptavio — 45
28) I'll take both. Not a binary thing :) by kamarvt — 45
29) Slavery = Capitalism. by Bush Bites — 44
30) Because Obama Knows Nothing About Africa. by Gooserock — 44
31) I am not in law enforcement. It is not my job... by Meteor Blades — 44
For an explanation of How Top Mojo Works, see mik's FAQing Top Mojo

TOP PHOTOS, May 10, 2014: Enjoy jotter's wonderful PictureQuilt below. Just click on the picture and it will magically take you to the comment that features that photo. Have fun, Kossacks!

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site