Skip to main content

My brother e-mailed me:

Remember 1-14-2009.

That's the day we officially became a Banana Republic.

By a 5-4 ruling the Supreme Court voted today to effectively gut the 4th Amendment as a meaningful limitation on police power.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled today (PDF file) that evidence gathered illegally by police as the result of defective search warrants is admissible in court.

Officers in Coffee County arrested petitioner Herring based on a warrant listed in neighboring Dale County’s database. A search incident to that arrest yielded drugs and a gun. It was then revealed that the warrant had been recalled months earlier, though this information had never been entered into the database . . .

Held: When police mistakes leading to an unlawful search are the result of isolated negligence attenuated from the search, rather than systemic error or reckless disregard of constitutional requirements,the exclusionary rule does not apply.

Translation: If the cops screw up, but get lucky and find something anyway, tough ta-tas for you, Mr. Private Citizen.

Better yet, If the cops decide they want to go after you, but can't get a legitimate warrant, they can fabricate one and later claim it was a "negligent" but innocent mistake. The burden of proof will then be on YOU, Mr. Private Citizen, to prove "systemic error or reckless disregard of constitutional requirements," and we know how much time, money and good ol' American can-do spirit you have to do that, right?

Banana republic, indeed.

Guess who the four dissenters were?



UPDATE (11:31 p.m. PST): It took me quite a while to get back to the computer - sorry - and now this little semi-rant went and made the Rec List. I'm afraid I won't be able to respond to many of the comments, but I will go through them. Thanks for reading!

UPDATE 2 (10:05 a.m. 1-15-09): What a wonderful, well-informed, erudite discussion the comments to this diary have produced!  I dashed this diary off as a mini-rant late yesterday, just before I had to run out the door, and by the time I got back there were nearly 500 comments.  This clearly is one of those diaries that makes the Rec List not because of the contents of the diary itself, but because of the substantive and thought-provoking nature of the discussion that follows.

What I have learned in reading through at least a portion of the comments is that in fact the Fourth Amendment was eviscerated long before yesterday’s decision; it seems the Leon decision of 1984 kicked in the door, as it were, to allow in a "good-faith" exception to the exclusionary rule.  Inasmuch as Justice Ginsburg (who wrote yesterday’s dissenting opinion) was not seated on the Court at the time of that ruling, yesterday's case was a prime opportunity for her to weigh in, as it was for the three other dissenters.

I stand by my original assessment: that the five justices in the majority, in ruling as they did yesterday, further cemented the ability, and increased the likelihood, of governmental agencies to abuse the "good-faith" exception to the exclusionary rule.  Negligence is negligence, and whether a citizen's fundamental rights are violated by an authority figure wielding a gun or one wielding a keyboard, the net result is the same: an unconstitutional deprivation of liberty.

I was frankly shocked by the number of commenters who expressed the logic, "if you're innocent, you don't have anything to worry about."  I thought - wrongly, evidently - that the last eight years of the BushCheney regime's conduct of the "war on terror" had sufficiently given the lie to that logical fallacy.  Sadly, even among readers of this site, I can see that my sanguine belief was wrong

Again, thanks so much for reading - and for commenting!

Originally posted to Important if True on Wed Jan 14, 2009 at 04:28 PM PST.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

skybluewater, Leslie in CA, Deep Dark, N in Seattle, chase, Alumbrados, Superskepticalman, Ed in Montana, Angie in WA State, Alfred E Newman, SteveLCo, herb superb, Julian, RedMeatDem, Bill in Portland Maine, Cowalker, murphy, skyesNYC, debcoop, XOVER, lipris, burrow owl, Anton Sirius, TKinVT, Gooserock, Dvd Avins, Unstable Isotope, machopicasso, whataboutbob, maynard, kainah, theboz, mattman, janinsanfran, TocqueDeville, RunawayRose, Bob Love, lazbumm, scrape, tnichlsn, Sprinkles, karlpk, dengre, tommurphy, exotrip, MsSpentyouth, Wintermute, Lipstick Liberal, SanJoseLady, bramish, shayera, eeff, Mnemosyne, ThirstyGator, Pompatus, figdish, marjo, lesliet, lzachary, SallyCat, BenGoshi, CivicServant, bumblebums, zeroooo, givmeliberty, nightsweat, expatjourno, zeitshabba, redtravelmaster, silence, Birdman, strengthANDwisdom, Heart of the Rockies, humbucker, Dave in DC, upnatom65, Gustogirl, EvieCZ, concernedamerican, bronte17, conchita, cskendrick, landrew, mentaldebris, anotherCt Dem, SecondComing, OCD, srkp23, CoolOnion, peace voter, RabidNation, PBnJ, buckhorn okie, barath, roses, khloemi, JuliaAnn, javelina, peraspera, dqueue, jbeach, superba, DiMe, ornerydad, Ohiocrat, ctsteve, Cedwyn, ginatx, CocoaLove, sele, Eddie C, wader, bigmama, recontext, baad, Oke, kharma, menodoc, psnyder, Lynwaz, nancelot, danthrax, sockpuppet, oldjohnbrown, Stand Strong, Dallasdoc, Dr Colossus, DeadB0y, pat bunny, crkrjx, brainwave, gmb, PaulVA, yet another liberal, churchylafemme, Penny Century, On The Bus, defluxion10, nika7k, never forget 2000, snakelass, hazzcon, tabbycat in tenn, rockhound, Greg in TN, razajac, FLDemJax, RebeccaG, produceus, under the bodhi tree, Timbuk3, lcrp, welshvalleymaid, Pohjola, fritzrth, walkshills, frostieb, Cablep, Oaktown Girl, bwintx, econlibVA, AllisonInSeattle, WV Democrat, mungley, randallt, WisVoter, Hillbilly Dem, KayCeSF, OrangeClouds115, tomjones, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, poemworld, Dr Seuss, kmbo, vacantlook, tipsymcstagger, boran2, faithfull, maggie sarah, Frank Vyan Walton, wolverinethad, sawgrass727, ebbinflo, sxwarren, davidkc, luvmovies2000, Recovering Southern Baptist, tovan, mediaprisoner, Bluesee, Tarindel, radarlady, Tinfoil Hat, supak, NoMoreLies, bellevie, enough, blueyedace2, m16eib, Five of Diamonds, baccaruda, stormcoming, CTPatriot, revbludge, saralee, OpherGopher, PBen, corvo, Alice Venturi, DrFood, Irons33, elkhunter, panicbean, clammyc, DocGonzo, truong son traveler, craigkg, Valtin, tomfool, Clem Yeobright, dewtx, stitchmd, Brooke In Seattle, reflectionsv37, boofdah, Blissing, lennysfo, owlbear1, cfk, EastCoastShock, Sun Tzu, jimstaro, pandawoman, jimreyn, where4art, GreyHawk, lotlizard, QuickSilver, Skid, brenda, babatunde, jane123, sunbro, Isara, SBandini, Savvy813, shiobhan, wiscmass, sodalis, Lisa Lockwood, distraught, dsteffen, bunsk, Cory Bantic, Hannibal, Spathiphyllum, empathy, Arsenic, tigerdog, viscerality, Land of Enchantment, kathny, Asinus Asinum Fricat, Paper Cup, fhcec, bently, noweasels, begone, lgmcp, skywriter, SoulCatcher, martini, LeftOverAmerica, coolhappyMax, Showman, Shirl In Idaho, redcedar, trashablanca, Sanuk, hlee1169, MissInformation, tarheelblue, tommymet, Pinko Elephant, vigilant meerkat, cybersaur, ripple, ferallike, BlueInARedState, quotemstr, Kimball Cross, dopper0189, HoundDog, Ellicatt, Yellow Canary, duckhunter, seefleur, victoria2dc, martyc35, glamberson, technomage, Samwoman, buhdydharma, ccmask, The Wizard, rhetoricus, IvanR, cliffradz, Wary, VictorLaszlo, Albatross, carolita, raincrow, greenearth, goodasgold, Imipolex, NBBooks, DarkestHour, triv33, tecampbell, MJ via Chicago, eglantine, bubbanomics, nonnie9999, gooderservice, gatorcog, nilocjin, Libby Shaw, Crashing Vor, pi1304, NC Dem, real world chick, FireCrow, njheathen, Terminus, Caoimhin Laochdha, JVolvo, NearlyNormal, CTLiberal, Preston S, el cid, PJHood, MarciaJ720, ZombyWoof, ER Doc, Unitary Moonbat, Randolph06, Pilgrim X, Turbonerd, blitz boy, rage, JugOPunch, rsie, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, Dianna, va dare, fiddlingnero, The Lighthouse Keeper, Stripe, means are the ends, RantNRaven, Dreaming of Better Days, kurt, liberalpercy, tallmom, airmarc, crystal eyes, Bernie68, bstotts, Picot verde, Granny Doc, louavul, duha, blueintheface, markthshark, sasher, illusionmajik, Nulwee, ZenTrainer, Aaa T Tudeattack, AntKat, BentLiberal, bcchamp, ammasdarling, subav8r, pale cold, lams712, AmericanRiverCanyon, One Pissed Off Liberal, robbk, RagingGurrl, pgm 01, DrSteveB, marykk, out of left field, Feeling Blue, jessical, Fredly, Haningchadus14, Kaiju, dmh44, Cottagerose, FWIW, possum, milkbone, DUKETYPE, moodyinsavannah, DocbytheBay, MikeTheLiberal, Dartagnan, jetskreemr, suburi, Great Uncle Bulgaria, maxalb, drbloodaxe, Outrider, Sam from Ithaca, ramsfan, JeremyA, yowsta, david mizner, greenchiledem, ezdidit, shruticounseling, DWG, sfbob, joyful, davehouck, Strabo, bnasley, malharden, Kyle the Mainer, Rex Manning, dconrad, jayden, jedennis, Aunt Martha, mauro7inf, twistedflatcat, thursdays child, jnhobbs, millwood, Moderation, dgil, Rumarhazzit, Got a Grip, leonard145b, electric meatball, skod, Puffin, JML9999, Zydekos, homerun, eyesoars, Prof Haley, cacamp, Bikemom, Hens Teeth, Terra Mystica, Empower Ink, gizmo59, crystaljim, Red no more, dsgood, JDWolverton, GANJA, fayeforcure, rogerdaddy, Devsd, gimmeshelter, condorcet, Blue Town, oolali, wayoutinthestix, rontun, BlueTape, homoaffectional, rikyrah, Aureas2, bythesea, VA gentlewoman, OutCarolineStreet, Rick Winrod, lineatus, wagdog, monkeybrainpolitics, alex valgus, tofumagoo, royce, boatjones, hwmnbn, pickandshovel, Missys Brother, MsWings, Jeff Y, rubine, mnguy66, mofembot, noddem, Rachel Griffiths, ClapClapSnap, Gemina13, PJ Jefferson, petulans, fool mee once, Jacques, luckylizard, chalatenango, nokkonwud, DixieDishrag, RoscoeOfAlabama, Dewey Kneadleeders, BYw, Blueslide, Executive Odor, dont think, marketgeek, Oxy, billybam, Mike Taylor, immigradvocate, cactusflinthead, BuyLocal, Diogenes2008, Reframing the Debate, forgore, jedley, Fiddlegirl, Celtic Merlin, wv voice of reason, JesusFists, 1BQ, plumbobb, Bule Betawi, Rhysling, Ran3dy, Florene, rubyclaire, Psychotronicman, smellybeast, MufsMom, ReallyEvilCanine, hippie bitch, arainsb123, Mr Tentacle, DontTaseMeBro, Neon Vincent, MTmarilyn, Rick Aucoin, litoralis, Unseen majority, ALifeLessFrightening, StuckInGA, The Dead Man, gdwtch52, DynamicUno, An Affirming Flame, Carol in San Antonio, CanyonWren, Stranded Wind, Inky99, Rabbithead, dark daze, Norm in Chicago, Partisan Progressive, sweeper, h bridges, ProgressiveMan, velvet blasphemy, butchergirl, VoteAqui, Yalin, rini6, politicalrunt, Daily Activist, Mercuriousss, BDsTrinity, followyourbliss, worldly1, Framlingham, Ivey476, Kaili Joy Gray, ZilV, Bord weall, Lopez99, pnn23, obscuresportsquarterly, COwoman, kevinpdx, drlevant, deutschluz, aztronut, histOries Marko, Munchkn, IreGyre, 57andFemale, Muzikal203, ArthurPoet, brushysage, azadmanish, Enrika, AkaEnragedGoddess, deviant24x, RogerDodger, ratmach, isabvella, Larsstephens, Lazar, ladygreenslippers, dalys, parse this, Carl Brutanananadilewski, ppl can fly, kydoc, BasketCase, oohdoiloveyou, oceanrain, oaktownadam, TNThorpe, MotleyC, HKPhooey, everyoneismad, winkster, VenturaProgressive, LaughingPlanet, Gangster Octopus, robertacker13, eXtina, dditt, politik, amk for obama, fidellio, El Ochito, on board 47, chrome327, wvmom, Ronald Singleterry, your neighbor, atxcats, 2questions, BonnieSchlitz, Eddie L, Nurse Jeckell, LouP, NY brit expat, samanthab, pixxer, Marja E, ItsSimpleSimon, paradise50, scarlet slipper, DrFitz, aggregatescience, rfall, WattleBreakfast, JRandomPoster, jdacal, swansong50, roystah, MsGrin, kissmygrits, Murchadha, keonhp, BasiX, Quote Me, sidious666, Actbriniel, anaxiamander, JerichoJ8, Kai99, ladyducatnip, nampa45, BrowniesAreGood, Colorado is the Shiznit, electronicmaji, heart of a quince, wildlife advocate, poorbuster, ardyess, the national gadfly, Mistral Wind, BillyElliott, FarWestGirl, The Son of the Devil Himself, kevin k, sallym, Civil Writes Activist, blueinmn, miranda2060, Victory of Renegades, incognita, rk2, sjr1, fabina12, AgnesBee, UtopianPablo, Sark Svemes, yellow is my favorite color, Edgewater, ilovecheese, pensivelady, Lets Elect A Progressive President In 2012

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site