Skip to main content

In Ping Fu's book Bend, not Break: A Life in Two Worlds, the description of her life in Shanghai before the Cultural Revolution does not seem like an average family's life in Shanghai at all. It was even better than an upper middle class American family. Her Shanghai papa and mama had a three-story house, a front yard and a back yard, all enclosed with a gate, and the house was not far from the business district, Nanjing Road. For a family of two adults and six children, their evening meals would have four appertizers, one soup, and eight main dishes. This was less than four years after a nation wide famine that killed thirty million people, in a communist society where Mao himself declared that he would only have four dishes and a soup for each meal. How could this be possible?

Let me try to figure this one out.

Ping Fu said that her Shanghai papa ran a factory that made threads. Reading from the description in the book, her Shanghai mama was probably a housewife. There were six children including Ping. They lived in a house described in the book as:

Our family house was peaceful rather than showy, a three-story and three-section villa connecting to a courtyard with a front gate that opened onto the main street of our neighborhood. Surrounding the complex, a stone wall decorated with an ornate iron fence shielded the serene interior from the unpredictable outside world.

Curved, handcrafted iron and stone balconies adorned the south facade, letting in warm light on sunny days and offering a panoramic view. Standing there, you could glean something of our lives in the early 1960s: the imposing headquarters of the Soviet Friendship Society looming large amid the boutiques and businesses that lined the city's famous Nanjing Road.

This was a huge house by Chinese standard. Her Shanghai family must have been very, very wealthy before the Cultural Revolution. In fact, such a luxurious life might be too rosy a picture of bourgeoisie life under communist rule in Shanghai. Yet there is still something missing in this picture. Where were the servants? There were no mention of any servant in the Shanghai part of the book. The most likely place that servants would have appeared, the scene was like this:
While my older siblings were off at school, I would spend afternoons with Shanghai Mama in the kitchen. She said that food must appeal to all five senses: aroma, color, texture, taste, and love. I'd hang on to her legs amid the sizzle and steam and chopping sounds as she prepared the traditional dinners we enjoyed each night: four appetizers, one soup, and eight main courses.
We will address the problem with the food later. But note here that Shanghai mama cooked a huge meal everyday, without any help. And she managed to keep a three-story, three-section house clean everyday without any help.

But in China during the 1960's, for a family who lived in such a huge house, it would be unlikely not to have any servants. This was the description of the life of the wealthy in Shanghai before the Cultural Revolution in Cheng Nien's Life and Death in Shanghai:

Not many private people in Shanghai lived as we did seventeen years after the Communist Party took over China. In this city of ten million, perhaps only a dozen or so families managed to preserve their old lifestyle, maintaining their original homes and employing a staff of servants. The Party did not decree how the people should live. In fact, in 1949, when the Communist army entered Shanghai, we were forbidden to discharge our domestic staff lest we aggravate the unemployment problem. But the political campaigns that periodically convulsed the country rendered many formerly wealthy people poor. When they became victims, they were forced to pay large fines or had their income drastically reduced. And many industrialists were relocated inland with their families when their factories were removed from Shanghai. I did not voluntarily change my way of life, not only because I had the means to maintain my standard of living, but also because the Shanghai municipal government treated me with courtesy and consideration through its United Front Organization.
You see, in communist Shanghai, if you were a capitalist, you were forced to keep your servants. It might be that for some unknown reasons Ping Fu's family really did not have any servants, despite they clear need and that they could afford them. It was more likely that simply because Ping Fu never lived there, she assumed that since it was communist China, even her aunt's family did not have servants.

Later I will provide solid proof that she did not live in Shanghai during her childhood. But before that let me offer another absurdity in her book, the food in Shanghai. Let's go back to the text I cited earlier:

While my older siblings were off at school, I would spend afternoons with Shanghai Mama in the kitchen. She said that food must appeal to all five senses: aroma, color, texture, taste, and love. I'd hang on to her legs amid the sizzle and steam and chopping sounds as she prepared the traditional dinners we enjoyed each night: four appetizers, one soup, and eight main courses. My favorite dish was crabmeat with ginkgo nuts in mint mango sauce.
Ping Fu was born in 1958 in Nanjing. The above scene should have occurred before she started school. In Shanghai, the government requires children start first grade when they reach age of seven which would be 1965 or 1966. The scene above should have happened after she could remember things but before she started school. That puts the scene between 1961 and 1965. What happened in China during that time? A great famine in which 30 million people died of starvation during the beginning of this period. Food ration was imposed everywhere in China, including Shanghai, and continued until after Mao's death in 1976. With severe shortage of food, people were lucky to have one dish on their table. Even the number one capitalist family in all of China, the Rong family, who also lived in Shanghai and whose son Rong Yiren later became the vice president of China (in the 1990's), was only having one dish (soy braised pork) for their meal and it was considered a luxury. Yet here we have an unknown, relatively wealthy merchant family enjoying "four appetizers, one soup, and eight main courses" each night! Not only it was so soon after the greatest famine in China's history, it was supposedly under a ruthless communist rule. Would you believe this story?

Her favorite dish was "crabmeat with ginkgo nuts in mint mango sauce". Many critics have raised questions about this. Mango sauce was never heard of in China in the 1960's. If Ping Fu's family were able to get it, they must have bought it from overseas and somehow slipped it through the tight customs control by the communist government. I have no idea how plausible that was. But it certainly sounded like an 1001 nights tale.

Finally, the real proof that Ping Fu never lived in Shanghai. When Ping Fu described that she had never flown in an airplane before leaving for the US, she said:

As I settled into my seat aboard the aircraft, the vent blasted warm air at my forehead. It occurred to me that this was my first experience of temperature-controlled air. I had never flown in an airplane, though I had spent most of my childhood sliding down aircraft wings at an abandoned airfield and dreaming of becoming an astronaut. I had never traveled anywhere outside of China. The farthest I had been from Nanjing, the city of my birth, was Suzhou University, where I had studied journalism and literature.
There are two big clues in this paragraph that tell us where she really lived during her childhood.

First, there was an abandoned airfield not far from her home, because she had spent "most of my childhood sliding down aircraft wings." This was not once, twice, occasionally, or for a year or two. This was "most of my childhood." If Ping Fu spent most of her childhood in Shanghai, then where was this abandoned airfield in Shanghai? Historically, there had been a total of four airports built in Shanghai. Three are still in use today: Shanghai Hongqiao International Airport, Shanghai Pudong International Airport, and Shanghai Longhua Airport. These are certainly not abandoned and had not been abadoned in the past either. One old airport, Jiangwan Airport, was still in use until 1994. None of these airports was abandoned during the 1960's.

Where was this abandoned airfield then? The answer is the Ming Palace Airport in Nanjing. Ming Palace Airport was the first civilian airport in Nanjing and was located at the center of Nanjing. It was abandoned in 1956. It was only a few blocks from the Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, where Ping Fu's father was a professor. The time matches - it was recently abandoned and new constructions had not been built. The location matches - it was close to her home, but only if she lived in Nanjing. From this description in her book, it is clear that Ping Fu spent her childhood in Nanjing, not in Shanghai. The whole story in Shanghai was fabricated.

The second big clue I already mentioned in a previous diary. She stated that the farthest she went before leaving for the US was Suzhou University. But if the book was correct, she spent first half of her childhood in Shanghai and second half in Nanjing. Suzhou is midway between Shanghai and Nangjing. This could not be possible. The only logical conclusion is that she was in Nanjing throughout her childhood. The Shanghai childhood was just a fantasy.

Originally posted to xgz on Thu Feb 07, 2013 at 07:36 AM PST.

Also republished by Progressive Friends of the Library Newsletter.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  Just faciinating the way you point out the reality (5+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    xgz, freerad, hailanzhiguang, gc10, mythatsme

    of her fantasy.  Why did Ping Fu do this?  I should ask her, but I doubt she will  reply with honesty since she  fills her book with falsehoods.  Your deconstruction is just brilliant and a service to all those who would seek the truth and value our friends in China.  I do know there are issues between us, but friends have issues.  I also know that there is the issue of Tibet and I would hope that someday this would be resolved with good grace between all parties.  But today, I want to enjoy your work here xgz and thank you for staying engaged even though some have been unkind to you.  

    Persistence is the way to knowledge.

    •  Thanks. I have learned a lot from friends here (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      freerad, hailanzhiguang

      Tibet is a complex issue that does not have simple answers. My view on Taiwan has changed a lot since I came here, and now I am 100% in support of Taiwan independence. But Tibet is a different problem. There are other issues involved that I don't see any way of resolving. For example, about 1/3 to half of all adult male in Tibet are non-productive monks. Right now they are sustained by subsidies from Chinese government. I cannot imagine what would happen when this subsidy is cut off.

      In any case, I don't see Tibetan independence will lead to a democratic Tibet. What I see is that a democratic China will lead to a better Tibet.

    •  My theory is that she was born in Shanghai (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      hailanzhiguang, mythatsme

      Her Shanghai mama and papa are actually her real parents. She was the 6th of 6 children. Her Nanjing parents at that time did not have any children. So her Shanghai parents gave her to her Nanjing parents. This must have been very traumatic for her when she learned this. That's why she is making up a story of her living in Shanghai, with her real parents.

      Of course this is just speculation.

  •  what a fantasy! (2+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    xgz, Catte Nappe

    From personal conversations with Chinese friends and my reading, most Chinese remember those years far, far differently. Hunger was widespread in the famine years and I can't believe her family held on to a massive home through the Cultural Revolution.
    People I know who were growing up at that time were happy to get a single egg for a birthday! Multiple courses? Hard to believe.

    George W. Bush: the worst Republican president SO FAR.

    by Chun Yang on Thu Feb 07, 2013 at 09:40:18 AM PST

    •  just a revised opinion here (0+ / 0-)

      I looked her up on Wikipedia and realize she wrote about that time in Shanghai as before the Cultural Revolution, when she was quite young. I would give more  leeway to someone who has childhood memories of nice meals, because they could have seemed grand when they were not. People recall details in a fuzzy way when they are quite young, although it is a stretch to imagine someone having food during the famine years. I certainly know people whose parents were sent to the countryside, who lived with other relatives, and those stories are valuable.

      George W. Bush: the worst Republican president SO FAR.

      by Chun Yang on Thu Feb 07, 2013 at 09:52:34 AM PST

      [ Parent ]

      •  RIght. Except that (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        hailanzhiguang

        she was never in Shanghai, as one can see from her description of her childhood in other parts of the book. I consider the abandoned airfield near her home and the statement that she never went further than Suzhou as conclusive evidence that she lived in Nanjing all the time before going to college.

        •  Details matter (3+ / 0-)
          Recommended by:
          xgz, FG, Catte Nappe

          A couple of add-ons:
          1. Shanghaiis love crab, but not crab in mango-mint sauce. This description sounds like someone has no clue about Shanghai. IF she lived in Shanghai for some time, she would have known that the most memorable food would include breakfast steam-fry dumpling, little wonton soup, and fresh water crab, (yummy!) steamed whole crab, eat with vinegar-ginger sauce. This is in the very DNA of Shanghaiis. If she knows about the neighborhood described in the book, she should brag a bit about Royal Russian-French bakery.

          2. Servants! Haha, dead on. It was very common to have helpers/maids/servants in those day. It didn't take a mega rich family to get one since we had one till about 1968 and we were not that rich.

  •  Interesting (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    xgz

    She had a recent post on HuffPo defending other kinds of discrepancies, and too oftern her answer is "a typo", or "she mis-remembered", or "the article about her mis-spoke".  I suspect it is only a matter of time before a full unraveling.

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/...

    "No one life is more important than another. No one voice is more valid than another. Each life is a treasure. Each voice deserves to be heard." Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse & Onomastic

    by Catte Nappe on Thu Feb 07, 2013 at 11:01:10 AM PST

    •  No unraveling, she is just clamping up (0+ / 0-)

      http://geomagic.com/...
      and blaming it on a smear campaign by Chinese government.

      Playing victim is always the first choice when someone is caught lying.

      •  That may not work for her (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        xgz

        Enough loose threads and pretty soon a lot more people are tugging to see what they can unearth, too. And the media are not kind to people who write books under false pretenses. Of course, it also matters how "big" the book is.

        One recent(ish) example:  Mortonson's "Three Cups of Tea"
        http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/...

        The biggest scandal was probably Frey's "Million Little Pieces", because the Oprah endorsement made it a way bigger best seller.

        Another thing that often seems to spur outrage, as is true of the two above, is if the book is considered "inspiring".

        "No one life is more important than another. No one voice is more valid than another. Each life is a treasure. Each voice deserves to be heard." Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse & Onomastic

        by Catte Nappe on Thu Feb 07, 2013 at 11:55:51 AM PST

        [ Parent ]

        •  Pathetic liar have to lie (1+ / 0-)
          Recommended by:
          xgz

          I don't know how some people develop this personality disorder, they are compelled to lie. It must feel good to do so for their twisted and sick mind. The sad thing is that many people chose to believe lies, which adds fuel to lairs' passion to make lies bigger.
          I am waiting for xgz to comment on gang rape. There is a huge gap between people lived in China in those days and westerners who didn't. It is very hard to some Westerners to accept the fact that on this matter, it was much safer then (during cultural revolution) than today. Rapists got death sentences. Gang rape? They would kill her for cover-up if it happened in daylight.

  •  She studied journalism and literature in college (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    xgz

    is also a lie. Suzhou University back then was called Jiangsu Normal College, which trained teachers for primary and secondary schools. Journalism is not a discipline at a teachers college. She mostly likely majored in Chinese, the equivalent of English major in the US.

    •  Good point (0+ / 0-)

      She may also have claimed a PhD in Chinese Literature from Nanjing University at one point, because when I searched online, I found this:

      http://www.zoominfo.com/...

      Education

          post-graduate degree , Chinese literature
          BS degree , computer science
          University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
          MS Degree , computer science
          University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
          MA , Chinese literature
          Suzhou University
          PhD , Chinese literature
          Nanjing University

      This is a website that automatically searches for someone's information and collects them. If it finds a new degree from someone's resume, it puts the new degree on this page. So it is an archive of someone's resume in a sense. This means that at some point in the past, Ping Fu had claimed that she had a PhD from Nanjing University in her resume.

      Interesting, isn't it?

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site