I watched the roll out of President Obama's nomination to fill Justice Stevens' seat on the High court this morning. I was then overwhelmed by an endless string of Chattering Class paid hairdos chanting in unison, "But, what is her story?"
It continued all day, as each broadcaster on TV and radio joined the chorus. Indeed, I became so entranced with the abject silliness of the commentary I had two TV's and two separate radios on, in order to not miss a single, succinct demonstration of the depths to which we have fallen.
Here we have a woman who is widely viewed as brilliant in the most outstanding company. A woman who has taught and practiced law for nearly 3 decades. A former Clerk to Thurgood Marshall!! And, all they can say is "What is her story?"
Do we now evaluate everyone in public life on the basis of the heart wrenching tales they can spin of their upbringing? Do we need to parade strife, and difficulty before we examine the qualifications of some one to fill a job of such importance and prestige that, unless they can grovel in the mire of some imaginary "real America" we no longer will consider them worthy of elevation?
This has really gotten beyond stupid!
Everything we think and do is not filtered through the artificial lens of American Idol, or Survivor. Every national security decision should not be measured against Jack Bower. And every person who seeks to fill a highly complex and demanding role in the national government does not have to bare their bum so we may check for incriminating scars.
When did we, as a country, become so convinced that gossip, and personal disclosure, are the path to competence. When did we decide that trivial events in the life of an educator should determine if we accept her training, and intellect as suitable, and indeed sufficient, for appointment to the Court?
The media may think the chatter and gossip are important. The Republicans may think that striding around and preening about their imaginary power to effect outcomes is important. But we, the thinking public, must stand up and cry, "Enough"!
I want a judicial cast to thinking, skilled judge of people, and the intellectual heft to weigh complex matters of law.
I frankly don't give a FUCK about her "story"...