This is going to be a short diary, just to promote Ezra Klein's great suggestion today.
Specifically, after noting that the GOP has responded to Obama's proposal for a bi-partisan health care summit with a list of demands that amount to a ransom note, he recommends that Obama agree to all of them in return for one simple matter: an agreement for an up-down vote, with no filibuster.
The GOP will never accept, but I think this is great politics.
First, Ezra recites the demands of Boehner and Cantor:
- "Assuming the President is sincere about moving forward on health care in a bipartisan way, does that mean he will agree to start over?"
- "Does that mean he has taken off the table the idea of relying solely on Democratic votes and jamming through health care reform by way of reconciliation?"
- "If the President intends to present any kind of legislative proposal at this discussion, will he make it available to members of Congress and the American people at least 72 hours beforehand?"
- "Will the President include in this discussion congressional Democrats who have opposed the House and Senate health care bills?"
- "Will the President be inviting officials and lawmakers from the states to participate in this discussion?"
- "The President has also mentioned his commitment to have 'experts' participate in health care discussions....Will those experts include the actuaries at the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), who have determined that the both the House and Senate health care bill raise costs?"
- "Will the special interest groups that the Obama Administration has cut deals with be included in this televised discussion?"
- "Will the President require that any and all future health care discussions, including those held on Capitol Hill, [be televised]?"
Understandably, Ezra remarks that "these are not folks who concern themselves with the appearance of good faith. The only thing missing is an obscure riddle that Obama must answer before he can speak to Mitch McConnell."
Still, he argues that Obama should:
agree to literally every one of the GOP's demands -- including the ones that don't make any sense -- in return for one, simple promise: The final legislation is guaranteed an up-or-down vote in the House and the Senate. No filibusters. No delays. No procedural tricks. If the GOP wants a clean process, I bet a deal can be struck here.
Again, I don't believe for a second that the GOP would accept such a deal. But I do think that such an approach would be great politics for Obama.