Skip to main content

Justice Scalia
Back in 1990, the Supreme Court of the United States was confronted with quite a sticky situation: Alfred Smith and Galen Black had been fired from their jobs with a private drug rehabilitation organization because they ingested peyote for sacramental purposes at a ceremony of the Native American Church, of which both are members. Their applications for unemployment compensation were denied, however, because they were determined to be ineligible because they had been discharged for work-related "misconduct."

They appealed, saying this violated their rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.

But to Justice Scalia and the five justice majority decision in Employment Division v. Smith, the issue of when a person could exempt himself from a generally-applicable law wasn't a tough one at all.

(Continue reading below the fold)

Justice Scalia explained:

We have never held that an individual's religious beliefs excuse him from compliance with an otherwise valid law prohibiting conduct that the State is free to regulate. On the contrary, the record of more than a century of our free exercise jurisprudence contradicts that proposition. As described succinctly by Justice Frankfurter in Minersville School Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Gobitis, 310 U.S. 586, 594-595 (1940):
Conscientious scruples have not, in the course of the long struggle for religious toleration, relieved the individual from obedience to a general law not aimed at the promotion or restriction of religious beliefs. The mere possession of religious convictions which contradict the relevant concerns of a political society does not relieve the citizen from the discharge of political responsibilities.
(Footnote omitted.) We first had occasion to assert that principle in Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145 (1879), where we rejected the claim that criminal laws against polygamy could not be constitutionally applied to those whose religion commanded the practice. "Laws," we said,
are made for the government of actions, and while they cannot interfere with mere religious belief and opinions, they may with practices. . . . Can a man excuse his practices to the contrary because of his religious belief? To permit this would be to make the professed doctrines of religious belief superior to the law of the land, and in effect to permit every citizen to become a law unto himself.
Id. at 166-167.

Subsequent decisions have consistently held that the right of free exercise does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a

valid and neutral law of general applicability on the ground that the law proscribes (or prescribes) conduct that his religion prescribes (or proscribes).
United States v. Lee, 455 U.S. 252, 263, n. 3 (1982) (STEVENS, J., concurring in judgment); see Minersville School Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Gobitis, supra, 310 U.S. at 595 (collecting cases).
Justice Scalia reminded his fellow justices of the Court's 1982 decision in United States v. Lee, where Amish plaintiffs protested having to collect taxes for Social Security, since they didn't believe in government support programs as a matter of conscience. In that case, Chief Justice Burger (mmm ... burger ...) explained for a unanimous Court:
The obligation to pay the social security tax initially is not fundamentally different from the obligation to pay income taxes; the difference — in theory at least — is that the social security tax revenues are segregated for use only in furtherance of the statutory program. There is no principled way, however, for purposes of this case, to distinguish between general taxes and those imposed under the Social Security Act. If, for example, a religious adherent believes war is a sin, and if a certain percentage of the federal budget can be identified as devoted to war-related activities, such individuals would have a similarly valid claim to be exempt from paying that percentage of the income tax. The tax system could not function if denominations were allowed to challenge the tax system because tax payments were spent in a manner that violates their religious belief.
He adds:
Congress and the courts have been sensitive to the needs flowing from the Free Exercise Clause, but every person cannot be shielded from all the burdens incident to exercising every aspect of the right to practice religious beliefs. When followers of a particular sect enter into commercial activity as a matter of choice, the limits they accept on their own conduct as a matter of conscience and faith are not to be superimposed on the statutory schemes which are binding on others in that activity.
As a constitutional matter, this is been there, done that territory.

Originally posted to Adam B on Fri Feb 10, 2012 at 08:19 AM PST.

Also republished by Pro Choice and Daily Kos.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

kos, Bob Johnson, deminva, Thumb, JekyllnHyde, Alumbrados, fladem, Superskepticalman, Angie in WA State, Mimikatz, Sylv, nota bene, TXdem, dwellscho, PrahaPartizan, Bill in Portland Maine, Mogolori, hester, murphy, grollen, ogre, teacherken, deben, Phoenix Rising, Cali Scribe, TrueBlueMajority, livosh1, iceman, Bob Love, newjeffct, MouseThatRoared, Sherri in TX, Heather in SFBay, billlaurelMD, Andrew C White, shayera, celdd, eeff, saluda, xynz, devtob, elfling, WI Deadhead, SallyCat, musicsleuth, exNYinTX, lady sisyphus, kissfan, opinionated, concernedamerican, Zinman, 88kathy, justme, lorell, Einsteinia, Silverleaf, parker parrot, annrose, SoCalJayhawk, Ian S, sharman, CoolOnion, highacidity, mikidee, themank, Bionic, shanikka, mkfarkus, BuckMulligan, CanisMaximus, ovals49, ivote2004, Clues, marylrgn, itskevin, Boxers, Nate Roberts, edie haskell, Cedwyn, dksbook, lulusbackintown, psnyder, danthrax, TexDem, virginislandsguy, Ender, JimWilson, texasmom, HeyMikey, Jujuree, penguins4peace, Steven Payne, Catte Nappe, emobile, Timbuk3, lcrp, Brian82, Democratic Hawk, MeToo, dkmich, outragedinSF, AllisonInSeattle, zerelda, ybruti, randallt, Deward Hastings, bablhous, rambler american, solesse413, The Gryffin, Josiah Bartlett, Sybil Liberty, sebastianguy99, Limelite, J Orygun, Gowrie Gal, weelzup, rapala, Skennet Boch, davidincleveland, ExStr8, maybeeso in michigan, bloomer 101, radarlady, RaveON, jrooth, UncleCharlie, Explorer8939, Jaxpagan, stlawrence, Chinton, democracy inaction, irate, offred, kitchen sink think tank, craigkg, basquebob, neatnate, dewtx, juliesie, drewfromct, Brooke In Seattle, david78209, miketocci, madmommy, fixxit, eru, indiemcemopants, majcmb1, Dem Beans, HugoDog, skralyx, Kayakbiker, rosabw, Overseas, skyounkin, Ice Blue, ivorybill, AnotherMassachusettsLiberal, SBandini, mph2005, Aint Supposed to Die a Natural Death, peacestpete, sgary, littlewren, ChuckInReno, Paper Cup, xaxnar, ThatSinger, begone, debedb, dedwords, SoulCatcher, third Party please, elliott, LeftOverAmerica, Showman, Shirl In Idaho, Jennifer Clare, Sanuk, hlee1169, BachFan, lovelylight, irishwitch, LeighAnn, myboo, vigilant meerkat, 417els, Mr Bojangles, BlueInARedState, dharmafarmer, emeraldmaiden, 8ackgr0und N015e, Yellow Canary, technomage, smokeymonkey, Shliapnikov, luckydog, kck, Lefty Coaster, SherriG, oldmanriver, StrayCat, HairyTrueMan, twigg, gpoutney, bubbanomics, paul2port, Native Light, real world chick, OMwordTHRUdaFOG, myrealname, ER Doc, Unitary Moonbat, middleagedhousewife, MBNYC, Pilgrim X, justiceputnam, bumbi, Cenobyte, thenekkidtruth, IL clb, stlkaper, doingbusinessas, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, frankzappatista, MadMs, Koleppski, lemonsieur, AllanTBG, markthshark, Little, OHdog, Aaa T Tudeattack, NonnyO, krwheaton, DBunn, pat of butter in a sea of grits, ammasdarling, Tamar, old wobbly, A Mad Mad World, Cronesense, Habitat Vic, hawaii2, Wanda517, Loudoun County Dem, ColoTim, gloriana, FishOutofWater, DvCM, LillithMc, tbirchard, HeartlandLiberal, Matt Z, terabytes, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, sfbob, Geek of all trades, Shadowmage36, bnasley, NoMoJoe, Seneca Doane, artisan, second gen, uscar, cyncynical, SeaTurtle, jnhobbs, millwood, jhop7, gchaucer2, carpunder, pioneer111, Wreck Smurfy, Rumarhazzit, uciguy30, GeorgeXVIII, journeyman, leonard145b, madgranny, cloudbustingkid, Prof Haley, the1sage, vet, on the cusp, gizmo59, rmonroe, JDWolverton, MKinTN, wayoutinthestix, DarkHawk98, ScottyUrb, Alexandre, Involuntary Exile, bythesea, skohayes, CDH in Brooklyn, lineatus, thetadelta, Its any one guess, mikeconwell, Greasy Grant, monkeybrainpolitics, Lujane, tofumagoo, pamelabrown, carver, catly, WoodlandsPerson, noddem, kyril, glendaw271, petulans, costello7, TexanJane, psilocynic, JamieG from Md, dzog, watercarrier4diogenes, statsone, Purple Priestess, fayea, JBL55, oldliberal, legendmn, clent, maggiejean, prettygirlxoxoxo, plumbobb, Fogiv, ARS, RenMin, juca, socalmonk, don mikulecky, cantelow, banjolele, be the change you seek, bondibox, Nebraskablue, Norm in Chicago, Methinks They Lie, Tara the Antisocial Social Worker, jennylind, CamillesDad1, DefendOurConstitution, petral, MKSinSA, asym, thestructureguy, Keith Pickering, winkk, stevenwag, vadasz, 57andFemale, jfromga, nancat357, Leftcandid, Terranova0, Larsstephens, cassandraX, Its the Supreme Court Stupid, commonmass, Christy1947, political junquie, confitesprit, rb137, FogCityJohn, LaughingPlanet, Observerinvancouver, stunzeed, Crabby Abbey, angelajean, freeport beach PA, appledown, ATFILLINOIS, CrissieP, Arenosa, tb mare, ItsSimpleSimon, DerAmi, DeanObama, ThirtyFiveUp, Texnance, kimalanus, cocinero, Oh Mary Oh, soithoni, soaglow, cany, Actbriniel, Onomastic, cdkipp, spindr27, redlum jak, kerflooey, Miniaussiefan, kamrom, Dretutz, kayak58, Bob Duck, jardin32, cooper888, Cintimcmomma, ObamOcala, FarWestGirl, lexalou, kiwiheart, pbgv23, cleduc2, NormAl1792, GrogInOhio, Rock Golf, trumpeter, boophus, marleycat, susanala, IllanoyGal, thomask, BarackStarObama, political mutt, muddy boots, antooo, chira2, sound of progress, Wood Dragon, rlk, Mets102, Vatexia, Friendlystranger, Hayate Yagami, blue aardvark, SoCalSal, weinerschnauzer, thejoshuablog, jham710, Regina in a Sears Kit House, aerie star, Mentatmark, SouthernLiberalinMD, ChiTownDenny, bassinduo, Auriandra, allergywoman, Colin Curtis, boredwitnuts, jacey, Cordyc, JTinDC, Heart n Mind, anodnhajo, Inkberries, Siri, foucaultspendulum, marinero, barkingcat, AnnieR, Sandi Behrns, Deep Texan, Nice Ogre, Trotskyrepublican, exatc, Evolutionary, Yonkers Boy, xenothaulus, David Kroning II, peachcreek, restondem, doroma, qannabbos, ricklewsive, Margd, Scott Campbell, tytalus, thePhoenix13, micwazoo, Denver11, George3, wasatch, Marjmar, mumtaznepal, Adam AZ, Portlaw, bumiputera, Canis Aureus, Fracturedchaos, koseighty, Greenfinches, Jonathan Hoag, MugWumpBlues, countwebb, NinetyNineNorth, Eric Twocents, glorificus, ZenManProject, Bud Fields, Setsuna Mudo, dhcallahan, Yastreblyansky, paccoli, lina, LaraJones

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site